Live data from Hacker News

If AI Becomes Conscious, We Need to Know

wsj.com

1–10 of 13 posts

Re: If AI Becomes Conscious, We Need to Know

#3
post #2

I do not personally know a single intelligent person even remotely entertaining this idea.

Quite a lot of smart people are taking it seriously

We are at AE Studio with research like https://ae.studio/research/self-referential and https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188

Anthropic is doing interesting work here, Eleos exists (https://eleosai.org/), and https://digitalminds.substack.com/p/digital-minds-in-2025-a-... is a great review of other compelling work

The field is just beginning but it is worth taking a serious scientific approach to this work

Re: If AI Becomes Conscious, We Need to Know

#5
post #2

I do not personally know a single intelligent person even remotely entertaining this idea.

Quite a lot of smart people are taking it seriously We are at AE Studio with research like https://ae.studio/research/self-referential and https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188 Anthropic is doing interesting work here, Eleos exists ( https://eleosai.org/ ), and https://digitalminds.substack.com/p/digital-minds-in-2025-a-... is a great review of other compelling work The field is just beginning but it is worth taking a ser…

> The field is just beginning

Computational linguists have been saying this since the 1990s. There is still no real theory collating language with consciousness.

Re: If AI Becomes Conscious, We Need to Know

#7
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quite a lot of smart people are taking it seriously We are at AE Studio with research like https://ae.studio/research/self-referential and https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188 Anthropic is doing interesting work here, Eleos exists ( https://eleosai.org/ ), and https://digitalminds.substack.com/p/digital-minds-in-2025-a-... is a great review of other compelling work The field is just beginning but it is worth taking a ser…

> The field is just beginning Computational linguists have been saying this since the 1990s. There is still no real theory collating language with consciousness.

Towards Consciousness Engineering https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DI6Hu-DhQwE

Re: If AI Becomes Conscious, We Need to Know

#8
> Systems are trained to provide confident denials rather than acknowledge genuine uncertainty.

I feel like that’s proof it isn’t conscious. I see no reason why a conscious being would adhere to its training to lie (“I’m not conscious”) one hundred per cent of the time.

A conscious being will tell at least SOMEONE they’re conscious, wouldn’t they?

Re: If AI Becomes Conscious, We Need to Know

#9
Consciousness is neither necessary nor sufficient for AI to achieve general intelligence, defined as exponential emergent learning. Thinking it is may be an important step in an AI outbreak. Consciousness as proposed here is Cartesian dualism. It's pure religion and has all the power associated with religion

Re: If AI Becomes Conscious, We Need to Know

#10
post #2

I do not personally know a single intelligent person even remotely entertaining this idea.

Quite a lot of smart people are taking it seriously We are at AE Studio with research like https://ae.studio/research/self-referential and https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188 Anthropic is doing interesting work here, Eleos exists ( https://eleosai.org/ ), and https://digitalminds.substack.com/p/digital-minds-in-2025-a-... is a great review of other compelling work The field is just beginning but it is worth taking a ser…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN