Claude Code 2.0 Is Promising but Flawed

#1

Post by waprin » Thu, Oct 02, 2025, 3:27 PM UTC

Claude Code 2.0 Is Promising but Flawed
aiengineering.report

Re: Claude Code 2.0 Is Promising but Flawed

#2

Post by qafy » Thu, Oct 02, 2025, 3:34 PM UTC

This article does a good job of comparing functionality between codex and claude, but I see very little discussion here or elsewhere about the actual UX of the CLI tools. Codex is absolute garbage when it comes to the look, feel, and overall polish of the CLI experience (no syntax highlighting, no proper diff displays, no vim mode, poor visual differentiation of user vs agent messages, etc). Claude is a tiny bit better. However, both fall flat on their face compared to some open source agentic TUIs like Opencode, Crush, etc.

Re: Claude Code 2.0 Is Promising but Flawed

#3

Post by waprin » Thu, Oct 02, 2025, 3:38 PM UTC

qafy wrote: post #2

This article does a good job of comparing functionality between codex and claude, but I see very little discussion here or elsewhere about the actual UX of the CLI tools. Codex is absolute garbage when it comes to the look, feel, and overall polish of the CLI experience (no syntax highlighting, no proper diff displays, no vim mode, poor visual differentiation of user vs agent messages, etc). Claude is a tiny bit bett…

I was just focusing on a few specific things in the Claude Code 2 release notes, namely they added two features /rewind and /usage, and I was disappointed in both. It's also probably a little too long as is. And yeah I've heard a lot of people complain about the Codex CLI experience though in a previous post I mentioned many Redditors like this repo to improve it:

https://github.com/just-every/code

I haven't tried Crush nor even heard of Opencode so I'll have to check them out, thanks for the feedback.

Re: Claude Code 2.0 Is Promising but Flawed

#4

Post by qafy » Thu, Oct 02, 2025, 4:09 PM UTC

waprin wrote: post #3

qafy wrote: post #2

This article does a good job of comparing functionality between codex and claude, but I see very little discussion here or elsewhere about the actual UX of the CLI tools. Codex is absolute garbage when it comes to the look, feel, and overall polish of the CLI experience (no syntax highlighting, no proper diff displays, no vim mode, poor visual differentiation of user vs agent messages, etc). Claude is a tiny bit bett…

I was just focusing on a few specific things in the Claude Code 2 release notes, namely they added two features /rewind and /usage, and I was disappointed in both. It's also probably a little too long as is. And yeah I've heard a lot of people complain about the Codex CLI experience though in a previous post I mentioned many Redditors like this repo to improve it: https://github.com/just-every/code I haven't tried Cr…

I have tried just about every third party CLI / TUI and I personally like Opencode the most. It has the best UX and the fact it natively integrates LSP for the agent to interact with is excellent. It is limited to models available via API, so for example it couldn't use codex at launch.