Live data from Hacker News

The car is not the future: On the myth of motorized freedom

blog.scaramuzza.me

1–10 of 122 posts

Re: The car is not the future: On the myth of motorized freedom

#3
It's interesting how people's positions can be so different. As a European who has lived in two (european) countries with good and affordable transport, I've always been a happy public transport user... until a couple of years ago, that is. Much of the transport is now filled with unpleasant people, dirt, delays, etc which paired with the insane prices of housing in the "walkable" parts of cities, has made me 100% invested in the myth of motorized freedom.

Re: The car is not the future: On the myth of motorized freedom

#5
post #3

It's interesting how people's positions can be so different. As a European who has lived in two (european) countries with good and affordable transport, I've always been a happy public transport user... until a couple of years ago, that is. Much of the transport is now filled with unpleasant people, dirt, delays, etc which paired with the insane prices of housing in the "walkable" parts of cities, has made me 100% in…

And who do you think is most interested in such decay of public transportation?

Re: The car is not the future: On the myth of motorized freedom

#6
> In the early 20th century, streets were shared spaces: places where people walked, gathered, played.

That's an interesting way to look at compressed horse shit with streams of human waste running over the top of it.

Bear in mind the invention of sidewalks predates the automobile by thousands of years.

Re: The car is not the future: On the myth of motorized freedom

#8
post #3

It's interesting how people's positions can be so different. As a European who has lived in two (european) countries with good and affordable transport, I've always been a happy public transport user... until a couple of years ago, that is. Much of the transport is now filled with unpleasant people, dirt, delays, etc which paired with the insane prices of housing in the "walkable" parts of cities, has made me 100% in…

I have the same experience, but I wonder if I just got older and more spoiled or if non-car traffic really got worse

Re: The car is not the future: On the myth of motorized freedom

#9
"That's just like, your opinion, man."

The car is clearly not the best way to navigate a dense city. It is impractical to have, say, tower block apartments and also have a car for each resident. It is unreasonable to build enough parking for peak time around every destination that anyone might want to go to.

On the flip side - not everyone wants to live in a dense city, and people's opinions on this change throughout their lives. It was profit maximising and also a lot of fun for me to live in the inner city in my early to mid 20's. Now that I can afford to not maximally push my career I prefer the outer parts of the city / more rural areas, and that's where the car shines.

Re: The car is not the future: On the myth of motorized freedom

#10
post #3

It's interesting how people's positions can be so different. As a European who has lived in two (european) countries with good and affordable transport, I've always been a happy public transport user... until a couple of years ago, that is. Much of the transport is now filled with unpleasant people, dirt, delays, etc which paired with the insane prices of housing in the "walkable" parts of cities, has made me 100% in…

And who do you think is most interested in such decay of public transportation?

I'd say the decline is happening (in my experience) in most public services, not just transport.

But anyway, I'm purposely staying away from discussing politics here since it's pointless, so I'll just share my experience as a public transport end-user, and the rest can fill in the gaps with their perspectives.

Post reply on HN