Live data from Hacker News

Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuclear Submarine (2020)

twz.com

1–10 of 19 posts

Re: Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuclear Submarine (2020)

#3

Why are there firearms on the submarine? Do they open the hatch and shoot at the opponent's submarine in case the torpedos don't work?

Because submarines are still ships that can be boarded. This is more for defense of the crew vs offense.

Re: Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuclear Submarine (2020)

#4

Why are there firearms on the submarine? Do they open the hatch and shoot at the opponent's submarine in case the torpedos don't work?

Because submarines are still ships that can be boarded. This is more for defense of the crew vs offense.

Firing rounds inside a nuclear submarine? Isn't it like firing a gun inside a plane?

Re: Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuclear Submarine (2020)

#5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because submarines are still ships that can be boarded. This is more for defense of the crew vs offense.

Firing rounds inside a nuclear submarine? Isn't it like firing a gun inside a plane?

Yes. What's wrong with that?

A 9mm, buck shot, or even a 556 (which they are not using on a sub) is not piercing the pressure hull of a submarine. That's before considering all the other mass of metal and matter within the sub.

Re: Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuclear Submarine (2020)

#6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because submarines are still ships that can be boarded. This is more for defense of the crew vs offense.

Firing rounds inside a nuclear submarine? Isn't it like firing a gun inside a plane?

I mean, I guess there's more risk of ricochets and equipment damage on a sub than a ship? Regardless, a lot of "don't do that" things become "you might have to do that" things in a combat scenario.

Re: Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuclear Submarine (2020)

#8

Why are there firearms on the submarine? Do they open the hatch and shoot at the opponent's submarine in case the torpedos don't work?

Possibility of mutiny, sabotage or just someone becoming dangerous because of personal conflicts or mental illness.

Re: Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuclear Submarine (2020)

#9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because submarines are still ships that can be boarded. This is more for defense of the crew vs offense.

Firing rounds inside a nuclear submarine? Isn't it like firing a gun inside a plane?

There are a lot of things that don't react well to bullets in a submarine. One Jack Ryan comes to mind...

Re: Nukes, Nubs And Coners: The Social Hierarchy Aboard A Nuclear Submarine (2020)

#10

Why are there firearms on the submarine? Do they open the hatch and shoot at the opponent's submarine in case the torpedos don't work?

The idea that a navy vessel wouldn't be equipped to provide its own security in port or dispatch an armed team on a launch is a non-starter.
Post reply on HN