Live data from Hacker News

Apple At Its Worst: It's Time to Stop Censoring Apps

readwriteweb.com

1–10 of 63 posts

Apple At Its Worst: It's Time to Stop Censoring Apps

#1
While not as horrifyingly Orwellian as it could be, the fact that the biggest company in U.S. history makes decisions about which content is too "objectionable" for its customers is unsettling.

Apple At Its Worst: It's Time to Stop Censoring Apps
readwriteweb.com

Re: Apple At Its Worst: It's Time to Stop Censoring Apps

#2
People that keep writing articles like this should not buy Apple. Apple is going to do what they're going to do. Either accept it or buy Android. Those are your options.

But let's be serious, Apple risks "consumer trust"? Not in any way that is likely to be measurable.

Re: Apple At Its Worst: It's Time to Stop Censoring Apps

#3

People that keep writing articles like this should not buy Apple. Apple is going to do what they're going to do. Either accept it or buy Android. Those are your options. But let's be serious, Apple risks "consumer trust"? Not in any way that is likely to be measurable.

Either accept it or buy Android.

Or Windows Phone, looking like a stronger alternative all the time.

Re: Apple At Its Worst: It's Time to Stop Censoring Apps

#4

People that keep writing articles like this should not buy Apple. Apple is going to do what they're going to do. Either accept it or buy Android. Those are your options. But let's be serious, Apple risks "consumer trust"? Not in any way that is likely to be measurable.

Either accept it or buy Android. Or Windows Phone, looking like a stronger alternative all the time.

Does Windows Phone solve these issues? Ie, is there review process actually better than Apple's? Or do they have similar support to (the overwhelming majority of) Android phones for loading alternative app stores? I haven't really seen much evidence one way or the other at this point.

Re: Apple At Its Worst: It's Time to Stop Censoring Apps

#5

People that keep writing articles like this should not buy Apple. Apple is going to do what they're going to do. Either accept it or buy Android. Those are your options. But let's be serious, Apple risks "consumer trust"? Not in any way that is likely to be measurable.

Either accept it or buy Android. Or Windows Phone, looking like a stronger alternative all the time.

I intentionally left it out, despite Windows 8 and the new Nokia looking gorgeous. It's the same problem. If MS says "No", then you're done. It's not your phone, you don't get to side-load the app.

Same problem as with Apple.

Re: Apple At Its Worst: It's Time to Stop Censoring Apps

#6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Either accept it or buy Android. Or Windows Phone, looking like a stronger alternative all the time.

I intentionally left it out, despite Windows 8 and the new Nokia looking gorgeous. It's the same problem. If MS says "No", then you're done. It's not your phone, you don't get to side-load the app. Same problem as with Apple.

It's the same fundamental problem, but side-loading isn't the only way to address it. People leaving the platform can apply market pressure on Apple to do the right thing.

Re: Apple At Its Worst: It's Time to Stop Censoring Apps

#8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I intentionally left it out, despite Windows 8 and the new Nokia looking gorgeous. It's the same problem. If MS says "No", then you're done. It's not your phone, you don't get to side-load the app. Same problem as with Apple.

It's the same fundamental problem, but side-loading isn't the only way to address it. People leaving the platform can apply market pressure on Apple to do the right thing.

It's not a very compelling message though: I'm leaving you Apple, because you censor apps, to another platform that also censors apps!

(Granted, in all fairness, the Android Market removes apps as well, but side loading is kind of the eventuality here).

Re: Apple At Its Worst: It's Time to Stop Censoring Apps

#9

People that keep writing articles like this should not buy Apple. Apple is going to do what they're going to do. Either accept it or buy Android. Those are your options. But let's be serious, Apple risks "consumer trust"? Not in any way that is likely to be measurable.

>> "Still, it's a new kind of gatekeeper, and it holds the keys to a platform used by millions of people around the world. While not as horrifyingly Orwellian as it could be, the fact that the biggest company in U.S. history makes decisions about which content is too "objectionable" for its customers is unsettling."

I am forever bewildered by consumers that have this sense of entitlement around a company and "demand" this action or that action.

It's their company. They can do whatever they want. If you don't like it, that's great. Dissenting opinions are a foundation of this great country. But Apple also deserves the right to not care what you think, and not care if you go somewhere else. The majority of consumers have no problem with it.

If Apple wanted to wall of the entire platform, they could do that. But instead they have created the biggest app market for mobile devices (from what I understand, please correct me if this is not 100% accurate, but the point remains it's huge). Does it suck that a few apps are rejected for seemingly dubious reasons? Sure, I guess it does for those developers. But I've been hearing dire warnings about mass exoduses and public outcries since the inception of the app store. Hasn't really happened besides a few edge cases that we see on Hacker News every other month or so.

To be honest, I feel that this particular app's story is only popular because it has to do with the politics of the drone program.

>> "Some consumers are already beginning to grow uncomfortable with Facebook's privacy policies, Google's targeted advertising, and other cases in which, whether justified or not, technology starts to feel a little creepy. Twitter takes protecting privacy and free speech very seriously, and even if most users don't notice or care yet, that stance will serve the company well as social media continues to part and parcel of our daily lives."

Got it. FB and Google evil. Twitter good.

Except that's not really true either. Twitter has worked with several law enforcement offices, particularly when identifying Occupy Wall Street protestors that were accused of crimes.

So I just don't find this article very credible on the facts, or the opinions persuasive at all.

Re: Apple At Its Worst: It's Time to Stop Censoring Apps

#10
post #7

Apple censoring apps in its own proprietary app-store isn't really a big deal to society as a whole. Apple censoring what other devices are allowed to exist outside their production-lines and what competing products customers are allowed to choose is.

It could be if they reach a certain size, especially as the web moves to mobile.
Post reply on HN