Live data from Hacker News

Please, FOSS world, we need something like ChromeOS

theregister.com

1–10 of 122 posts

Re: Please, FOSS world, we need something like ChromeOS

#6

Uhh…doesn’t a basic Debian install already do this? If you can’t be bothered to install basic af distro, then what is a ChromeOS clome going to do?

Not even remotely close.

This is why it was such a revolution when Ubuntu came out and quickly dominated the Linux desktop space. When it was new.

It took Debian and made it something approachable. But even then it was a 1/3rd of what is described as needed in the article.

Re: Please, FOSS world, we need something like ChromeOS

#7

Uhh…doesn’t a basic Debian install already do this? If you can’t be bothered to install basic af distro, then what is a ChromeOS clome going to do?

I think steamos would be a better example, also mentioned in the article. Focus on a single application by default, immutable A/B OS filesystems, but can be opened if desired.

Re: Please, FOSS world, we need something like ChromeOS

#8
The goal is banishing any and all questions of what to download, what desktop, what apps, packaging formats, software stores, user accounts, backing up, all of it: run the browser locally, sync the data – and only the data – to the cloud.

That is not really popular in the open source world. Who finances the cloud, is it open, who can read or sell your data?

Re: Please, FOSS world, we need something like ChromeOS

#9

Uhh…doesn’t a basic Debian install already do this? If you can’t be bothered to install basic af distro, then what is a ChromeOS clome going to do?

The author's point is to use an immutable or atomic system. Debian uses a traditional package manager and over time those packages can get in a weird state. Battery runs out during package update? Third party repo disappears? GPG key changes? Distribution eliminates 32-bit library support? Nvidia drivers change? Distribution deprecates Xorg? Your everyday user doesn't know how to deal with that.

An A/B partition scheme is very simple and the system as a whole is integration tested in CI. An OSTree based atomic system is pretty close, although there is some added complexity.

Not to mention Debian out-of-the-box is a pretty miserable experience for everyday users. Their Nvidia drivers won't work, they can't figure out how to install Chrome, videos won't play due to missing codecs, etc.

Post reply on HN