Live data from Hacker News

Chomsky on what ChatGPT is good for (2023)

chomsky.info

1–10 of 389 posts

Re: Chomsky on what ChatGPT is good for (2023)

#7
post #3

He should just surrender and give chatgpt whatever land it wants.

Manufactured intelligence to modulate a world of manufactured consent!

I agree with the rest of these comments though, listening to Chomsky wax about the topic-du-jour is a bit like trying to take lecture notes from the Swedish Chef.

Re: Chomsky on what ChatGPT is good for (2023)

#10
Chomsky is always saying that LLMs and such can only imitate, not understand language. But I wonder if there is a degree of sophistication at which he would concede these machines exceed "imitation". If his point is that LLMs arrive at language in a way different than humans... great. But I'm not sure how he can argue that some kind of extremely sophisticated understanding of natural language is not embedded in these models in a way that, at this point, exceeds the average human. In all fairness, this was written in 2023, but given his longstanding stubbornness on this topic, I doubt it would make a difference.
Post reply on HN