Live data from Hacker News

Encryption Is Not a Crime

privacyguides.org

1–10 of 222 posts

Re: Encryption Is Not a Crime

#3
Not a crime, but somehow our dear EU overloads try every year or so to make it a crime in any way possible (eg. chat control).

If we want to play in a world with full transparency, let's start with the politicians!

Re: Encryption Is Not a Crime

#4
There's an abstract argument template that I've noticed floating around. It goes like this:

  1. There's a thing T in the world, and that thing has negative outcomes X, Y, Z, and positive outcomes A, B, C.
  2. Some people believe that Y and Z are so bad, that they want to partly compromise C to diminish them.
  3. However that will never work! And they'll definitely also take B if we let them mess with C.
  4. Besides, C is so important, that we should accept Y and Z to have it.
I've heard it many times before. Reading this post feels like watching a rerun of Friends.

Re: Encryption Is Not a Crime

#5
It’s honestly annoying how often experts speak up about this, and still nothing changes. We’re stuck in the same cycle—fear gets in the way, and in the end, it’s our privacy and security that suffer. If anything, this should be a sign to invest in stronger encryption and better law enforcement tactics that don’t mess with the tools keeping us safe online.

Re: Encryption Is Not a Crime

#7

Not a crime, but somehow our dear EU overloads try every year or so to make it a crime in any way possible (eg. chat control). If we want to play in a world with full transparency, let's start with the politicians!

The same people who want to make encryption a crime (like Trump 45[0]) are using signal to discuss sensitive information without an audit trail. It's absolutely rules for thee.

0 - https://www.politico.com/story/2019/06/27/trump-officials-we...

Re: Encryption Is Not a Crime

#8

Not a crime, but somehow our dear EU overloads try every year or so to make it a crime in any way possible (eg. chat control). If we want to play in a world with full transparency, let's start with the politicians!

And like always they claim its to protect our children... Who could possibly argue against protecting children?

Re: Encryption Is Not a Crime

#9
post #4

There's an abstract argument template that I've noticed floating around. It goes like this: 1. There's a thing T in the world, and that thing has negative outcomes X, Y, Z, and positive outcomes A, B, C. 2. Some people believe that Y and Z are so bad, that they want to partly compromise C to diminish them. 3. However that will never work! And they'll definitely also take B if we let them mess with C. 4. Besides, C is…

My favorite version of it is "Let's ban air because terrorists breathe".

Re: Encryption Is Not a Crime

#10

Not a crime, but somehow our dear EU overloads try every year or so to make it a crime in any way possible (eg. chat control). If we want to play in a world with full transparency, let's start with the politicians!

And also apply it equally to ecommerce and homebanking.

Lets see how happy the voters are when they have to start walking to their Bank again every week, can't order their latest temu toxic waste product anymore and their GDP drops in half.

Post reply on HN