Live data from Hacker News

Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired

tokyoweekender.com

1–10 of 72 posts

Re: Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired

#4
> However, a wise man once said: “[It] ain’t about how hard you hit. It’s about how hard you can get hit and keep moving forward; how much you can take and keep moving forward.” Ujiharu may have lost Oda Castle nine times, but that means he also won it back eight times, almost always with smaller armies. His refusal to accept defeat and his iron will to get up and keep fighting is why many historians reject the “weakest samurai warlord” nickname and instead refer to him as “The Phoenix.”

Love this paragraph from the article.

Re: Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired

#5
post #3

Hard times create strong men. Strong men create good times. Good times create weak men. And, weak men create hard times. This guy is all of those men, like 10 times over.

This is such a dumb saying. Good times are created by weak people working together to defeat strong people. Most hard times are created by "Strong Men" fighting each other. Just take a look around the world - is it countries under the sway of warlords that have the best times? Or is it countries where the institutions are stronger than the individuals, where rulers have been limited or deposed by groups of individually weaker people? Weak people don't create hard times - it's tyrants that do that.

Re: Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired

#6
post #3

Hard times create strong men. Strong men create good times. Good times create weak men. And, weak men create hard times. This guy is all of those men, like 10 times over.

This is such a dumb saying. Good times are created by weak people working together to defeat strong people. Most hard times are created by "Strong Men" fighting each other. Just take a look around the world - is it countries under the sway of warlords that have the best times? Or is it countries where the institutions are stronger than the individuals, where rulers have been limited or deposed by groups of individual…

Then those men you're calling „weak“ are actually strong...

Re: Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired

#7
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is such a dumb saying. Good times are created by weak people working together to defeat strong people. Most hard times are created by "Strong Men" fighting each other. Just take a look around the world - is it countries under the sway of warlords that have the best times? Or is it countries where the institutions are stronger than the individuals, where rulers have been limited or deposed by groups of individual…

Then those men you're calling „weak“ are actually strong...

Strong together. Strong, when they choose to support each other. Weak otherwise.

Re: Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired

#8
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is such a dumb saying. Good times are created by weak people working together to defeat strong people. Most hard times are created by "Strong Men" fighting each other. Just take a look around the world - is it countries under the sway of warlords that have the best times? Or is it countries where the institutions are stronger than the individuals, where rulers have been limited or deposed by groups of individual…

Then those men you're calling „weak“ are actually strong...

"Good times" is a property of the political system as a whole and has little to do with "strength of men" unless you bend backwards to redefine strength.

Re: Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired

#10
Man of the people:

> Ujiharu’s blind charges may actually have had a noble purpose. Japanese battles involving castles almost always turned into sieges, and those always ended the same way: with the nearby fields and peasant settlements being either destroyed to try and draw the lord out of the castle or looted to feed the occupying army. Some researchers believe that Ujiharu was trying to avoid a siege to save his subjects.

Post reply on HN