Live data from Hacker News

Why am I still on Twitter?

therectangle.substack.com

1–10 of 17 posts

Re: Why am I still on Twitter?

#5
It's very hard for me to fathom why people want to be on a platform that lies about it's commitment to free speech, is pay to win, and is run by one of the worst people in the world right now.

I never had a Twitter account, so perhaps my ignorance is showing.

Re: Why am I still on Twitter?

#6
> I’ve written about the platform’s array of issues before, but, in summary, the removal of the verified public figures and the introduction of the new Blue Ticks basically allowed people to pay for engagement.

I think the alternative was worse. Basically unseen employees at Twitter get to make judgement calls on who is noteworthy, with not much objective reasoning. I've seen people with 1k followers have a blue checkmark and then others with hundreds of thousands of followers not have one. And you even had instances where blue check marks were removed as punishment.

The only reasoning that made sense was politics, if you were a left wing author with a self published book of poems and 1k followers you had a good shot at a checkmark, and if you were right wing, you would have that check mark dangled over you. No clear process. And considering how influential these social media platforms are and how checkmarks effect discoverability, it made a huge difference. Instagram had the same thing and there were even stories of "influencers" sleeping with Meta employees to get verified.

Now anyone willing to pay a few dollars per month can have the same reach. There's a reason Instagram basically has this pay to play model and I think it's far better.

Also the fact that Twitter is the only (?) social media that pays its creators directly. No convoluted process, just if you're verified you get a check every once in a while and from what I've seen it's pretty substantial. The idea that social media companies should pay their creators has been around a while. It seemed deeply unfair that these billion dollar companies were created on the back of free labor. Reddit had worthless "gold" as a reward, but come on. This was a huge long overdue development in social media landscape that I don't think gets enough attention.

Re: Why am I still on Twitter?

#7

It's very hard for me to fathom why people want to be on a platform that lies about it's commitment to free speech, is pay to win, and is run by one of the worst people in the world right now. I never had a Twitter account, so perhaps my ignorance is showing.

Because it's where important information gets distributed and discussed

Because a lot of important people are on it

It's the social media platform that is the least "managed" by PR. In other words, you're more likely to have the person from the profile actually using the app rather than PR. I could imagine Mark Cuban is sitting on the can writing his on tweets, which is not true for his other communications.

Because you can actually get paid if you produce a lot of engagement

Or was your comment more rhetorical? Because there are valid reasons someone would use it.

Do you think you're more likely to get your speech censored on Twitter compared to TikTok, Instagram, Reels, Facebook, Bluesky, etc? I don't get this hangup like "oh they lied about free speech" when literally every other social media platform is worse.

Re: Why am I still on Twitter?

#9
What is even on Twitter? I don't think there's ever been one time I've said to myself "I wonder what's on Twitter today" and opened it just to see.

I must be doing something wrong because millions of people don't do this every single day.

Re: Why am I still on Twitter?

#10
> More than that though, there’s simply no good competitor. Maybe, one day, Bluesky can take over, but it’s too small and too self-congratulatory currently. Like most of these starter platforms, the majority of posts seem to be about the network itself, rather than the world outside of it.

I don't recognize the authors comment that it is only about Bluesky. It likely all depends on who you follow.

I have now been a few months on Bluesky and havent looked back. I noticed many thinkers I followed did continue on Bluesky and I noticed there is a much less toxic community which is a big win for my mental health.

Post reply on HN