Live data from Hacker News

Allstate used GasBuddy and other apps to track driving behavior: lawsuit

arstechnica.com

1–10 of 195 posts

Re: Allstate used GasBuddy and other apps to track driving behavior: lawsuit

#5
This is Allstate, the house, trying to maintain their edge over their customers, the players. If they get additional info that tells them you are an unsafe driver, then their odds of you not getting into an accident diminish and their goes their premiums, the bets.

Yah yah insurance reduces risks instead of adding it like gambling, but the analogies are still there.

Re: Allstate used GasBuddy and other apps to track driving behavior: lawsuit

#6
post #4

It makes sense to share your data with an insurance provider if you are a well-behaved driver. It is well-behaved drivers that subside the insurance cost of reckless drivers.

I think it makes sense to ... just not want to share generally.

Re: Allstate used GasBuddy and other apps to track driving behavior: lawsuit

#7
post #4

It makes sense to share your data with an insurance provider if you are a well-behaved driver. It is well-behaved drivers that subside the insurance cost of reckless drivers.

> It is well-behaved drivers that subside the insurance cost of reckless drivers.

People say this but it's not true. Bad drivers have higher premiums, and no one is subsidizing them.

It does make sense for good drivers to share, but only if they have opted in.

Re: Allstate used GasBuddy and other apps to track driving behavior: lawsuit

#8
post #4

It makes sense to share your data with an insurance provider if you are a well-behaved driver. It is well-behaved drivers that subside the insurance cost of reckless drivers.

Ahh yes, the "if you have nothing to hide" excuse for violating people's privacy.

Re: Allstate used GasBuddy and other apps to track driving behavior: lawsuit

#9
post #5

This is Allstate, the house, trying to maintain their edge over their customers, the players. If they get additional info that tells them you are an unsafe driver, then their odds of you not getting into an accident diminish and their goes their premiums, the bets. Yah yah insurance reduces risks instead of adding it like gambling, but the analogies are still there.

I like it when unsafe drivers pay the costs of the way they endanger all of us.

Re: Allstate used GasBuddy and other apps to track driving behavior: lawsuit

#10
post #4

It makes sense to share your data with an insurance provider if you are a well-behaved driver. It is well-behaved drivers that subside the insurance cost of reckless drivers.

> It is well-behaved drivers that subside the insurance cost of reckless drivers. People say this but it's not true. Bad drivers have higher premiums, and no one is subsidizing them. It does make sense for good drivers to share, but only if they have opted in.

They do pay higher premiums but that might not be enough to pay for a claim. The economics are often such that you price low risk drivers to subsidize higher risk drivers if realistically pricing the high risk drivers is not economical, i.e. would lead to losing business. It's a balance.
Post reply on HN