The anxiolytic effects of resistance exercise
pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
The anxiolytic effects of resistance exercise
1–10 of 14 posts
Re: The anxiolytic effects of resistance exercise
#2Oftentimes I find medical research not interesting, most of the people that do strength training know the anxiolytic effect, there is no need for an nth paper to say it, there is a need for research that explain why it is true.
Meta-analysis help in showing trends, it's kinda valuable per se, but there are meta-analysis that show important things that were previously difficult to find because they were scattered in the literature, and the litterature was not with the same sample of people. Here the insights are pretty small, there was not really a doubt about the effect of strength training. A better analysis would be 'which people do not benefit for anxiolytic effects doing sport'. That's unknown, do these people even exist?
Re: The anxiolytic effects of resistance exercise
#3Exercise is so good for so many things except fat loss, which everyone thinks it's good for.
Re: The anxiolytic effects of resistance exercise
#4Oftentimes I find medical research not interesting, most of the people that do strength training know the anxiolytic effect, there is no need for an nth paper to say it, there is a need for research that explain why it is true. Meta-analysis help in showing trends, it's kinda valuable per se, but there are meta-analysis that show important things that were previously difficult to find because they were scattered in t…
It's worth noting that this is a paper from 2014. The premise seems well-known now, but I wonder if it was as strong then?
I agree root cause analysis would be more interesting, but it wouldn't be justified until the base phenomena was validated.
Sure, people who do exercise think it helps stress and anxiety, but lots of people also find homeopathic remedies to be helpful. Papers like this show the former stand up under experimentation and the later don't.
Re: The anxiolytic effects of resistance exercise
#5Oftentimes I find medical research not interesting, most of the people that do strength training know the anxiolytic effect, there is no need for an nth paper to say it, there is a need for research that explain why it is true. Meta-analysis help in showing trends, it's kinda valuable per se, but there are meta-analysis that show important things that were previously difficult to find because they were scattered in t…
Science confirming "common knowledge" is still important not only to cement the common knowledge with supporting data but also to open avenues to find mechanisms, which also leads to your question:
> A better analysis would be 'which people do not benefit for anxiolytic effects doing sport'. That's unknown, do these people even exist?
If there was no scientific validation of the benefits this question wouldn't be able to be researched.
Re: The anxiolytic effects of resistance exercise
#6Oftentimes I find medical research not interesting, most of the people that do strength training know the anxiolytic effect, there is no need for an nth paper to say it, there is a need for research that explain why it is true. Meta-analysis help in showing trends, it's kinda valuable per se, but there are meta-analysis that show important things that were previously difficult to find because they were scattered in t…
Science confirming "common knowledge" is still important not only to cement the common knowledge with supporting data but also to open avenues to find mechanisms, which also leads to your question: > A better analysis would be 'which people do not benefit for anxiolytic effects doing sport'. That's unknown, do these people even exist? If there was no scientific validation of the benefits this question wouldn't be abl…
I totally agree on that, I was not saying that it is not important, I just found the paper lacking depth
Re: The anxiolytic effects of resistance exercise
#7Oftentimes I find medical research not interesting, most of the people that do strength training know the anxiolytic effect, there is no need for an nth paper to say it, there is a need for research that explain why it is true. Meta-analysis help in showing trends, it's kinda valuable per se, but there are meta-analysis that show important things that were previously difficult to find because they were scattered in t…
It's worth noting that this is a paper from 2014. The premise seems well-known now, but I wonder if it was as strong then? I agree root cause analysis would be more interesting, but it wouldn't be justified until the base phenomena was validated. Sure, people who do exercise think it helps stress and anxiety, but lots of people also find homeopathic remedies to be helpful. Papers like this show the former stand up un…
I think that in 2014 it was already well known, there are several meta-analysis that precede this work. yes research is important, even just to state common knowledge, I just find the paper lacking depth and sources, making it not that interesting.
There is no follow-up of this research by the authors, and their research is not really focused on something in particular, I've the impression that it's just another paper on the subject.
Re: The anxiolytic effects of resistance exercise
#8Oftentimes I find medical research not interesting, most of the people that do strength training know the anxiolytic effect, there is no need for an nth paper to say it, there is a need for research that explain why it is true. Meta-analysis help in showing trends, it's kinda valuable per se, but there are meta-analysis that show important things that were previously difficult to find because they were scattered in t…
It's worth noting that this is a paper from 2014. The premise seems well-known now, but I wonder if it was as strong then? I agree root cause analysis would be more interesting, but it wouldn't be justified until the base phenomena was validated. Sure, people who do exercise think it helps stress and anxiety, but lots of people also find homeopathic remedies to be helpful. Papers like this show the former stand up un…
there was a lot of popular science on sports training in the 1980s.. perhaps related to new, excellent measurement of blood content at different stages of exercise? a fallout of that science was the steriods era in US pro sports
Re: The anxiolytic effects of resistance exercise
#9Exercise is so good for so many things except fat loss, which everyone thinks it's good for.
Did you mean weight loss instead of fat loss perhaps?
Re: The anxiolytic effects of resistance exercise
#10Oftentimes I find medical research not interesting, most of the people that do strength training know the anxiolytic effect, there is no need for an nth paper to say it, there is a need for research that explain why it is true. Meta-analysis help in showing trends, it's kinda valuable per se, but there are meta-analysis that show important things that were previously difficult to find because they were scattered in t…
> most of the people that do strength training know the anxiolytic effect
Many people also thought drinking bleach prevents Covid. Whatever people NK and feel, it is important to have it confirm scientifically.