UK Farmers Trigger the Revolution – Politely
morningporridge.com
UK Farmers Trigger the Revolution – Politely
1–8 of 8 posts
Re: UK Farmers Trigger the Revolution – Politely
#2There's some interesting points in the comments on this article, make sure to read those too as they bring some clarity to the situation which UK farming faces.
Re: UK Farmers Trigger the Revolution – Politely
#3The issue with inheritance tax on farms is that it's viscerally obvious that it's just confiscation of land through the back door. A farm that has to pay x% IHT just ends up being x% smaller each generation.
Where x is anything other than a token amount it's basically impossible to generate x% of the land value at transfer in excess of all other costs such as wages, equipment, a reasonable salary for the family and any workers etc.
There's an argument to be had that land redistribution is something we want, but the Government really isn't being honest about that being what they are intentionally pursuing.
Re: UK Farmers Trigger the Revolution – Politely
#4Rich farmers should distribute their lands to poor ones
Re: UK Farmers Trigger the Revolution – Politely
#5> If a farm generates £50k of income per annum, what makes it worth the £3 mm at which UK inheritance tax will likely become payable?
Answer: it is worth the £3 mm only because land prices have been inflated by people purchasing land for tax planning purposes. Regardless of the rights and wrongs of the governent’s solution, the market has been distorted by an anomaly in the tax system.
Re: UK Farmers Trigger the Revolution – Politely
#6According to the government this inheritance tax change can end up generating at most £0.4-0.5 billion, which does nothing for its over £1,100 billion spending, there is no monetary justification for this change, only contempt for a class of people who work hard and earn next to nothing(in the UK).
I personally see inheritance tax itself being a deeply immoral construct, your estate was made out of money that was already taxed multiple times by multiple different types of taxes, instead of you being able to pass your hard earned wealth to your heirs, the state takes it away. If you owned a house your children might be forced to sell it because the tax on it could be 40%, if you got as mortgage in your early 30s, you probably paid it off in your early 70s which is close to the life expectancy of 78 if you are a man, so technically, you didn't really own anything and you were just a slave to the state.
Re: UK Farmers Trigger the Revolution – Politely
#7According to the government this inheritance tax change can end up generating at most £0.4-0.5 billion, which does nothing for its over £1,100 billion spending, there is no monetary justification for this change, only contempt for a class of people who work hard and earn next to nothing(in the UK). I personally see inheritance tax itself being a deeply immoral construct, your estate was made out of money that was alr…
I see multi-generational wealth as an immoral construct.
Re: UK Farmers Trigger the Revolution – Politely
#8According to the government this inheritance tax change can end up generating at most £0.4-0.5 billion, which does nothing for its over £1,100 billion spending, there is no monetary justification for this change, only contempt for a class of people who work hard and earn next to nothing(in the UK). I personally see inheritance tax itself being a deeply immoral construct, your estate was made out of money that was alr…
I see multi-generational wealth as an immoral construct.
What do you think should happen instead?