Live data from Hacker News

Blizzard-made Warcraft 1&2 remasters look like Zynga games made by blind duck

rockpapershotgun.com

1–10 of 18 posts

Re: Blizzard-made Warcraft 1&2 remasters look like Zynga games made by blind duck

#2
We're about 30 years too late to complain about the art style.

I don't disagree with the comparison of the visuals to flash games, but that's more or less all you can get to without a lot of backlash over completely changing the game's appearance, since the originals were very low-resolution highly cartoony things.

You could certainly have redone 1 and 2 in 3's engine, but that's a different market, in a lot of ways.

Re: Blizzard-made Warcraft 1&2 remasters look like Zynga games made by blind duck

#3
Is there a comparison image? I’d like to see screenshots of the original and the corresponding screenshots of the remastered version.

Update: the trailer shows the old and the new version at ~26s, direct link: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_iWMpW_C7Z0&t=26

Re: Blizzard-made Warcraft 1&2 remasters look like Zynga games made by blind duck

#4
post #3

Is there a comparison image? I’d like to see screenshots of the original and the corresponding screenshots of the remastered version. Update: the trailer shows the old and the new version at ~26s, direct link: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_iWMpW_C7Z0&t=26

The trailer they embed for the release announcement shows them swapping, since like the Diablo remaster, I believe you can realtime toggle the changes on and off.

Re: Blizzard-made Warcraft 1&2 remasters look like Zynga games made by blind duck

#5
post #3

Is there a comparison image? I’d like to see screenshots of the original and the corresponding screenshots of the remastered version. Update: the trailer shows the old and the new version at ~26s, direct link: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_iWMpW_C7Z0&t=26

I think the comparison would ruin the author’s argument.

Re: Blizzard-made Warcraft 1&2 remasters look like Zynga games made by blind duck

#6
Eh I mean it’s not that bad - this article is super short on details too, I need a unit-by-unit comparison describing an overall approach to the art style that changed between the original release and this one. This post is a glorified xitter rant basically. If I want three whiney paragraphs on a subject I’ll ask ChatGPT about it.

Re: Blizzard-made Warcraft 1&2 remasters look like Zynga games made by blind duck

#7

Eh I mean it’s not that bad - this article is super short on details too, I need a unit-by-unit comparison describing an overall approach to the art style that changed between the original release and this one. This post is a glorified xitter rant basically. If I want three whiney paragraphs on a subject I’ll ask ChatGPT about it.

Skip to around 0:36 in the launch trailer, they swap from the classic to the new graphics on the same scene.

Re: Blizzard-made Warcraft 1&2 remasters look like Zynga games made by blind duck

#8
post #3

Is there a comparison image? I’d like to see screenshots of the original and the corresponding screenshots of the remastered version. Update: the trailer shows the old and the new version at ~26s, direct link: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_iWMpW_C7Z0&t=26

The trailer they embed for the release announcement shows them swapping, since like the Diablo remaster, I believe you can realtime toggle the changes on and off.

Thanks, I wasn’t able to view the trailer on safari mobile in private mode (asks to sign it but I don’t have an account). But it worked fine on youtube - https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_iWMpW_C7Z0 if anyone else needs a link.

Re: Blizzard-made Warcraft 1&2 remasters look like Zynga games made by blind duck

#9
post #3

Is there a comparison image? I’d like to see screenshots of the original and the corresponding screenshots of the remastered version. Update: the trailer shows the old and the new version at ~26s, direct link: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_iWMpW_C7Z0&t=26

Comparison videos:

* Warcraft I: https://youtu.be/lhZL1zZTj74?si=95Fkue4cWWivJ7cf

* Warcraft II: https://youtu.be/KZ9Ac4WVW6Q

Re: Blizzard-made Warcraft 1&2 remasters look like Zynga games made by blind duck

#10

Eh I mean it’s not that bad - this article is super short on details too, I need a unit-by-unit comparison describing an overall approach to the art style that changed between the original release and this one. This post is a glorified xitter rant basically. If I want three whiney paragraphs on a subject I’ll ask ChatGPT about it.

Skip to around 0:36 in the launch trailer, they swap from the classic to the new graphics on the same scene.

I mean yeah, but that’s a trailer, it’s just marketing. I want the author to actually put some time into exploring and explaining to the audience, if they think they’ve got a point to make. This could just have been a headline and a link to the trailer.
Post reply on HN