Live data from Hacker News

ELIZA Reinterpreted: The world's first chatbot was not intended as a chatbot

arxiv.org

1–10 of 25 posts

Re: ELIZA Reinterpreted: The world's first chatbot was not intended as a chatbot

#5
Except it WAS intended as a chatbot... as a tool "for research into human-machine conversation and the important cognitive processes of interpretation and misinterpretation".

It's like saying the guy who invented the screwdriver didn't invent it because he was REALLY just trying to build a cabinet. The reason a tool was invented does not mean the tool isn't what the tool is.

Re: ELIZA Reinterpreted: The world's first chatbot was not intended as a chatbot

#6
Jeff is a HN user and his connection to ELIZA is pretty interesting. Many of the ELIZA chat bot clones were based on a version he wrote as a kid, that was published.

He and a group of researchers put effort into digging up the history of original implementation.

Interesting person!

Re: ELIZA Reinterpreted: The world's first chatbot was not intended as a chatbot

#8
post #5

Except it WAS intended as a chatbot... as a tool "for research into human-machine conversation and the important cognitive processes of interpretation and misinterpretation". It's like saying the guy who invented the screwdriver didn't invent it because he was REALLY just trying to build a cabinet. The reason a tool was invented does not mean the tool isn't what the tool is.

POSIWID.

Re: ELIZA Reinterpreted: The world's first chatbot was not intended as a chatbot

#9

Is arxiv just a blogging platform now? This isn't a research paper.

I think you misunderstand arxiv, blogging, and research papers.

(I've used/done extensively the three mentioned things before, including blogging in a research context)

arxiv is a preprint server. Blog posts can, sometimes, play the same role as research preprints. Research papers are fundamentally about having a _structured conversation_ about a topic.

This paper is arxiv at its best.

Re: ELIZA Reinterpreted: The world's first chatbot was not intended as a chatbot

#10

Jeff is a HN user and his connection to ELIZA is pretty interesting. Many of the ELIZA chat bot clones were based on a version he wrote as a kid, that was published. He and a group of researchers put effort into digging up the history of original implementation. Interesting person!

You can plug your interview.
Post reply on HN