Live data from Hacker News

Google rival Tuta complains to EU tech regulators about de-ranking

reuters.com

1–10 of 53 posts

Re: Google rival Tuta complains to EU tech regulators about de-ranking

#2
The article says March, which coincidences with this:

https://developers.google.com/search/blog/2024/03/core-updat...

It's possible Tuta caught a stray here because they recently changed their name from Tutanota[0], including the domain name. This update has the SEO world up in arms, in fact - the update is still rolling out, nearly two months after it was announced.

I'd love to be a fly on the wall in the Google Search team's offices to learn just how much machine learning is messing with the ability to properly understand intent -> rank content.

E: Semrush shows that they took a nosedive, but not a complete decimation[1].

E2: I take the initial edit back, looks like they got a classifier applied to their site, also known as the "Helpful Content Update":

https://tuta.com/blog/google-search-problem

It's a nasty classifier and not a single site has been reinstated from it[2] since Google began to apply it in Sep 2023.

[0]: https://tuta.com/blog/tutanota-is-now-tuta

[1]: https://i.imgur.com/E9ybteL.png

[2]: https://twitter.com/glenngabe/status/1781679769735545280

Re: Google rival Tuta complains to EU tech regulators about de-ranking

#3
post #2

The article says March, which coincidences with this: https://developers.google.com/search/blog/2024/03/core-updat... It's possible Tuta caught a stray here because they recently changed their name from Tutanota[0], including the domain name. This update has the SEO world up in arms, in fact - the update is still rolling out, nearly two months after it was announced. I'd love to be a fly on the wall in the Google Sea…

https://tuta.com/blog/google-search-problem

This article goes into much more detail about the issue.

Re: Google rival Tuta complains to EU tech regulators about de-ranking

#4
Off-topic: I am immensely happy with latest google update, because now if I search for something that is too obscure, google simply shows me an empty page with no results found, which tells me that I need to refine my search query. Previously, if such thing happened, I'd get a list of spam sites which does not include the query at all, or simply uses the query somewhere not visible on the page.

Re: Google rival Tuta complains to EU tech regulators about de-ranking

#5
post #4

Off-topic: I am immensely happy with latest google update, because now if I search for something that is too obscure, google simply shows me an empty page with no results found, which tells me that I need to refine my search query. Previously, if such thing happened, I'd get a list of spam sites which does not include the query at all, or simply uses the query somewhere not visible on the page.

I feel the opposite. Often I'm searching some obscure error message or function name from an open source project; I'd expect Google to at the very least provide a result linking to the Github page where the thing is defined, but nope, nothing. Bing on the other hand gives me exactly what I'm looking for in the first few results.

Re: Google rival Tuta complains to EU tech regulators about de-ranking

#6
It might not just be Google--I tried searching "encrypted email" in DDG and found nothing for pages and pages. Even saw AOL come up before any mention of Tuta. My guess is the name change, combined with prior bad reputation on the tuta.com domain (see http://web.archive.org/web/20190107213809/http://tuta.com/), is causing the issue across search engines.

Re: Google rival Tuta complains to EU tech regulators about de-ranking

#7
post #4

Off-topic: I am immensely happy with latest google update, because now if I search for something that is too obscure, google simply shows me an empty page with no results found, which tells me that I need to refine my search query. Previously, if such thing happened, I'd get a list of spam sites which does not include the query at all, or simply uses the query somewhere not visible on the page.

I feel the opposite. Often I'm searching some obscure error message or function name from an open source project; I'd expect Google to at the very least provide a result linking to the Github page where the thing is defined, but nope, nothing. Bing on the other hand gives me exactly what I'm looking for in the first few results.

This has been my experience. Google can now not even find substrings from source code found in thousands of GitHub repos. It's rapidly getting useless for programming.

Re: Google rival Tuta complains to EU tech regulators about de-ranking

#8
post #4

Off-topic: I am immensely happy with latest google update, because now if I search for something that is too obscure, google simply shows me an empty page with no results found, which tells me that I need to refine my search query. Previously, if such thing happened, I'd get a list of spam sites which does not include the query at all, or simply uses the query somewhere not visible on the page.

I feel the opposite. Often I'm searching some obscure error message or function name from an open source project; I'd expect Google to at the very least provide a result linking to the Github page where the thing is defined, but nope, nothing. Bing on the other hand gives me exactly what I'm looking for in the first few results.

Google doesn't seem to index all of github, which is very frustrating when looking for code strings or error messages that you know are included in some opensource project.

Re: Google rival Tuta complains to EU tech regulators about de-ranking

#9
post #4

Off-topic: I am immensely happy with latest google update, because now if I search for something that is too obscure, google simply shows me an empty page with no results found, which tells me that I need to refine my search query. Previously, if such thing happened, I'd get a list of spam sites which does not include the query at all, or simply uses the query somewhere not visible on the page.

I'd be with you here, if not that I've long learned to associate an empty results page with the search engine timeouting or otherwise breaking. Refreshing the page would usually fix it.

Re: Google rival Tuta complains to EU tech regulators about de-ranking

#10
post #4

Off-topic: I am immensely happy with latest google update, because now if I search for something that is too obscure, google simply shows me an empty page with no results found, which tells me that I need to refine my search query. Previously, if such thing happened, I'd get a list of spam sites which does not include the query at all, or simply uses the query somewhere not visible on the page.

Used to be able to just use quotes to find exact matches

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30130535

Post reply on HN