Live data from Hacker News

Twenty years maintaining the WiX Toolset

robmensching.com

1–10 of 70 posts

Re: Twenty years maintaining the WiX Toolset

#4
post #3

For those like me (I never used Windows) who do not know WiX; https://wixtoolset.org/ .

lol, from the title i was absolutely convinced that he was talking about https://www.wix.com/

I indeed clicked it because I thought that as well.

Re: Twenty years maintaining the WiX Toolset

#5
When Microsoft launched the (let's face it, baroque) complexity that is Windows Installer (MSI), we didn't get the WiX Toolset, instead we got an expensive proprietary profiling tool for capturing before/after snapshots, and an entry-level version bundled on the Windows 2000 CD which didn't really solve anybody's problem. No suprises then that the MSI format didn't immediately take over, and Microsoft would presume all the way to Intune that their customers were deploying MSI packages when mostly we weren't.

I always wondered what would have happened if the WiX Toolset had been available from the start, and I like to compare the more organic success of the Microsoft Deployment Toolkit (MDT) being more open and hackable as an example. I guess the time just wasn't right.

Re: Twenty years maintaining the WiX Toolset

#8
post #5

When Microsoft launched the (let's face it, baroque) complexity that is Windows Installer (MSI), we didn't get the WiX Toolset, instead we got an expensive proprietary profiling tool for capturing before/after snapshots, and an entry-level version bundled on the Windows 2000 CD which didn't really solve anybody's problem. No suprises then that the MSI format didn't immediately take over, and Microsoft would presume a…

I really tried to use msi back when it appeared but it wouldn't work in certain versions of Windows without installing something else before. I can't remember the details but it was self defeating.
Post reply on HN