Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What is your approach for managing personal digital assets?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 27 posts

Ask HN: What is your approach for managing personal digital assets?

#1
I've been facing this issue for quite a while and haven't come across a solution that meets my needs.

I have many files and digital content scattered everywhere. Some files and texts in my email accounts (personal and work). Some in Storage services such as Dropbox, GDrive, ... and some in messaging apps. There is also the photo gallery on my phone. These are photos, videos, text, pdfs, ... . The challenge comes in when I'm trying to find a specific file or info. I often find myself asking questions like:

- Where's the photo of me wearing a cap?

- Where are all my invoices from before 2023?

- Did my friend ever text me his phone number somewhere?

- ...

I'd really appreciate any advice or recommendations for tools or methods you've used that worked for you.

Re: Ask HN: What is your approach for managing personal digital assets?

#2
I religiously use Google contacts. It's the simplest way to keep people contacts up to date on Android.

I archive all important documents in specific folders by subject and date. This is backed up to back blaze with restic. https://restic.net/

I use https://ente.io for pictures. I convinced my wife to use it, and she agreed to auto share her photos so I don't nag her for copies. It had simple import from Facebook and Google.

I also keep extensive journals, which really helps to tie it all together. I can basically grep for hangouts, conversations, etc. https://jodavaho.io/tags/bullet-journal.html

I also separate work journal from personal, and have essentially a journal for each project. https://jodavaho.io/tags/bullet-journal.html again.

I religiously use Google calendar for all plans, you can easily search it for past events to get dates. See also journal.

I use task warrior, and use projects organized the same way as my project journal and file folders. https://taskwarrior.org/

So a project might be 'outrider/planner' and so the relevant docs are on ~/outrider/planner, tasks are in proj:outrider:planner and my notes are in docs dir with a common name like 'notebook.md' or logs/.md

It's really that combo of using same method for folder structure, task project structure, notes, docs that keeps my life sane. Grep and FZF make it very easy to search.

Re: Ask HN: What is your approach for managing personal digital assets?

#3
Personally I also scatter files across cloud, laptop and smartphone, with no plan or structure; files end up where I last used them.

For now that works well for me though. Sorting by last modified and starring or adding items to favorites also helps. Password managers are also useful when it comes to storing sensitive data.

Re: Ask HN: What is your approach for managing personal digital assets?

#4
I've faced (and am still facing) this problem as well. I don't think there's a good single solution, especially for finding specific photos.

My current imperfect approach is to use Raycast / Alfred as a meta search tool to find things in various places. It doesn't unify things but it makes searching multiple places low friction.

Some specific tools, in case it helps.

- invoices, contracts, etc. go into paperless-ngx. Physical documents get scanned in.

- miscellaneous or unorganized documents into Nextcloud

- custom solution for searching text messages

- no solution whatsoever for images. I think semantic image search might do the job, although I haven't explored what tools exist for that.

Edit: formatting

Re: Ask HN: What is your approach for managing personal digital assets?

#5
Tresorit is where all my stuff goes. Except photos from my phone, for that I use iCloud backup (not Photo sync - the encrypted full device backup)

My priorities for a solution for this was 1) Privacy 2) Security mostly in terms og availability (reliability) 3) works across the platforms the family uses, 4) do not want to spend any time managing the solution and 5) long term solution

I generally do not trust cloud services so Google Drive, Dropbox et al are not even in the discussion. Tresorit is an exception due to e2e encryption and company location (EU).

Tresorit is ridiculously expensive, and I pay for more iCloud storage. I have just accepted that if I want the priorities above (and esp. not having to managing it myself) I would have to pay for a quality product.

Proton (mail and drive) I would also trust for the same reasons I do Tresorit, and I think it’s less expensive, but it wasn’t around when I picked Tresorit

Edit: a big part of why Tresorit (and iCloud) solves the problem is actually not due to Tresorit, but being disciplined about sticking to only using one product. Sometimes that means not doing something I want if it’s not compatible with Tresorit, or accepting a more involved manual process. Like, MS Office documents I don’t use 365 and the Office storage (one drive), but the offline version of and a folder on disk synced to Tresorit.

Re: Ask HN: What is your approach for managing personal digital assets?

#6
I've moved to more and more plain-text or more common formats for others that will likely survive the test of time, such as JPEGs, PDFs.

So far, I'm also responsible for managing the digital assets of our family and the extended in-laws. Here is how I have organized so far, and there is a lot of room for improvement.

Every individual is a container (folder) and then is foldered further into the common ones -- medical/health, photos, documents, etc. So, if mother-in-law asked my wife to find the medical record for my father-in-law that we went to the clinic in AUG-2022, I go look at "/name/health/" and then is either in an "EventName" folder or a "Year/Date/Something". I can fine something within a few folders of separation for anything.

I tend to organize file, more aptly receipt, named something in the lines of "YYYY-MM-DD $xyz What was it.pdf". So, I know the date, the invoice/receipt value and what it might be without opening the file.

The photos are still in Apple Photos for convenience but is backed up every month to the highest resolution it was hot at in a JPEG and exported month as "/photos-backup/YYYY/photos-YYYY-MM" as part of my weekly, monthly, quarterly, and then yearly digital chores. As I do this regularly, they don't tend to pile up, even if I missed, say while traveling or I just got lazy and skip it.

The question I usually ask when using a tool/program is, “Can I walk out of this?”

Here is an example, when my daughter grows up enough and wants to own her digital assets, there is one folder with her and everything organized the way I've done, "Schools", "Health", "Creatives", "Photos", etc. She can then proceed the way she wants.

Of course, these are replicated across drives, cloud-drives, etc. My next fun project is to replicate my data across a few locations I frequent around the world -- a remote hilly hometown, the current home in Bangalore, another place I go frequently for work, etc.

(Typed in a bit of a haste. Will come back and edit.)

Re: Ask HN: What is your approach for managing personal digital assets?

#7
Keeping backups of everything in a centralized directory/drive is useful since regardless of where the content may be normally (phone, different system) if it gets backed up to one place then it makes it searchable/indexable.

Edit: I should mention the kinds of backups I prefer to keep for structured data are in non-binary formats, which helps with searches. Otherwise just keeping organization sensible for future-me helps a great deal.

Re: Ask HN: What is your approach for managing personal digital assets?

#8
For me, I use a combination of things and I keep regular backups of everything.

Photos: Google Photo

Notes: Nextcloud +Joplin

Documents and invoices: Google Drive

I didn't move photos and documents to Nextcloud because the features for viewing photos and editing documents are not as good as Google.

Re: Ask HN: What is your approach for managing personal digital assets?

#9
For long-term preservation of important digital assets, I strongly recommend using archival-grade DVDs. While cloud services like Google Drive have demonstrated remarkable reliability in file storage over the years, surpassing the performance of most consumer-grade hard drives and USB drives, DVDs offer unparalleled reliability for local storage. This is the only approach to ensure your files remain accessible and secure over +50 years timeframe.

Re: Ask HN: What is your approach for managing personal digital assets?

#10
I keep "important" (as in I might need them for taxes or be asked for them again later) papers all in one folder organized by year and I'm pretty good at putting things there when I need to.

The rest is spread out across 2 google drive accounts and a Hetzner Nextcloud instance. I was really uncertain about the reliability of NC when I started using it but now it's been so reliable for quite some time and I'm thinking of moving more stuff there. Even though Hetzner offers automatic backups I think I still need another backup but haven't figured that part out yet.

Oh also I use syncthing to keep a few folders synced between my laptop, phone, and NC instance.

I will say though I've been long interested and searched for some ways that people actually organize their folders and such but haven't see anything too useful. I guess as long as you have good search it isn't as important.

Post reply on HN