Live data from Hacker News

How to forget what you read

ckarchive.com

1–10 of 58 posts

Re: How to forget what you read

#3
As Katarina Janoskova says, "So you read a book. You finished it, liked it, maybe even recommended it to others. It changed your life slightly while you were reading it and for a bit afterwards. And then you moved on with your life." I like that. That says it more succinctly.

Re: How to forget what you read

#4
I used to take endless notes on .org documents and build myself small wiki sites in django...

You know what makes the difference?

Take a walk, or catch a train and think about what you read. Find the main ideas and how the material relates to yourself. Play with it and ask yourself questions about it.

Then next day try to answer them in paper without extra material. And only after that reread the book to check or find unsolved the answers.

Learning is hard. There is nothing as easy learning. The good news is that it can be hand AND fun.

About reading:

Engage in every sentence, ask yourself what the writer is trying to tell you in every sentence, after that translate it to imagination and relate it with yourself and what you already know.

There is shallow reading and deep reading. Deep reading is a must for technical books, but also a joy for fiction. I still remember so vividly the coldness and texture of the walls of the hobbit's first mountain tunnels despite haven't been told about it.

Re: How to forget what you read

#5
Last year, I aimed to read 30 books. But I realized I usually forgot most of the stuff, just remembering some main ideas. Really getting the hang of a topic takes time. So this year, I'll read fewer books but focus more on understanding what I'm reading.

Re: How to forget what you read

#6
Katarina Janoskova, linked in the article, writes:

> Is [reading] just a waste of time? Well, no, I don’t think so. Every book makes a mark. Even if it doesn’t stay in your conscious memory. Just as every single thing that happens to you does and every person you meet.

I once read a short essay by Patrick Süskind (author of "Perfume - The Story of a Murderer"). I am paraphrasing, but in it, he discusses his embarrassment that he cannot remember even major plot details or character names of great works of world literature, although he has read them multiple times and they deeply inspired his own work. He then makes an interesting speculation: if a book really and deeply influences you, then maybe actively remembering facts and insights of the book becomes harder and harder, because the book's ideas have been so deeply ingrained into your brain and thinking that you cannot remember them as facts independent of your own thinking. But this doesn't mean that you have "forgotten" them.

Re: How to forget what you read

#7
post #6

Katarina Janoskova, linked in the article, writes: > Is [reading] just a waste of time? Well, no, I don’t think so. Every book makes a mark. Even if it doesn’t stay in your conscious memory. Just as every single thing that happens to you does and every person you meet. I once read a short essay by Patrick Süskind (author of "Perfume - The Story of a Murderer"). I am paraphrasing, but in it, he discusses his embarrass…

I never cease to be surprised with the attempts to make everything productive nowadays. Of course, everyone can do whatever they want but it seems to me a symptom of how society works nowadays that instead of just enjoying the act of reading and remembering whatever details impact us, we obsess with being able to retrieve information from them

Re: How to forget what you read

#8
post #4

I used to take endless notes on .org documents and build myself small wiki sites in django... You know what makes the difference? Take a walk, or catch a train and think about what you read. Find the main ideas and how the material relates to yourself. Play with it and ask yourself questions about it. Then next day try to answer them in paper without extra material. And only after that reread the book to check or fin…

* Learning from a book is hard

Re: How to forget what you read

#9
I think there is more to be said about the topic that organically sticks to you.

I have realized that this depends a lot on what you are "up to" at the moment.

In my experience, I have a really hard time internalizing information about a topic that is far from some topic or work I'm engaged with at the moment.

This means, I think:

1. That you can to some extent influence what you are "up to".

2. That you should probably organize your reading and other learning activities around the seasons of thinking themes in your life [1]

[1] E.g. to me, that often means I'm into quite different themes during work days versus weekends, where I'm often exploring some slightly different topics.

Re: How to forget what you read

#10
Spot on. Just another symptom of a quantity obsessed culture. It's telling that people ask how many books did you read this year and not what was the best book you read about (a question of quality, over quantity).
Post reply on HN