Live data from Hacker News

Would You Pay $850 for an iPhone if Carrier Subsidies Disappeared?

techland.time.com

1–8 of 8 posts

Re: Would You Pay $850 for an iPhone if Carrier Subsidies Disappeared?

#3
I _did_ pay that for an unlocked iPhone, because I wanted to use it while traveling. (The savings paid for the phone on the first trip I made, compared to the execrable roaming/data charges I have experienced with AT&T in the past).

But I think aes256's point is valid. That iPhone you buy with a carrier subsidy does not cost $199.

In a fully-transparent world, you'd be able to bring your own phone and get a reduced monthly bill from your mobile carrier. Or you could buy a subsidized phone and pay more per month.

In a fully-transparent world, of course, the mobile carrier becomes commoditized. They hate that.

It can't come soon enough for me, as a customer, however.

Re: Would You Pay $850 for an iPhone if Carrier Subsidies Disappeared?

#4
post #2

'Carrier subsidies' are just an illusion. You are paying $850 for your top of the line iPhone, you just don't realise it because it's in the form of $40+ monthly instalments...

In Denmark, we do realize it. The Danish law requires companies to specify the minimum price for the phone for the contract period. If the phone has an initial price of $99, monthly contract is $49, and minimum contract period is 24 months, they must list $1176 as the minimum total price.

Check "mindstepris" (24 month contracts) at: http://www.telenor.dk/privat/mobil/mobil/iphone/

Re: Would You Pay $850 for an iPhone if Carrier Subsidies Disappeared?

#5
post #2

'Carrier subsidies' are just an illusion. You are paying $850 for your top of the line iPhone, you just don't realise it because it's in the form of $40+ monthly instalments...

I'd spend $600 on a new phone if my monthly bill was going to be $30.

Re: Would You Pay $850 for an iPhone if Carrier Subsidies Disappeared?

#7

I _did_ pay that for an unlocked iPhone, because I wanted to use it while traveling. (The savings paid for the phone on the first trip I made, compared to the execrable roaming/data charges I have experienced with AT&T in the past). But I think aes256's point is valid. That iPhone you buy with a carrier subsidy does not cost $199. In a fully-transparent world, you'd be able to bring your own phone and get a reduced m…

Yep. Cut $20/mo off my phone bill and I'll very happily buy my phone at full price.