Live data from Hacker News

PAROL6 Desktop Robot Arm

github.com

1–10 of 58 posts

Re: PAROL6 Desktop Robot Arm

#4
Interesting project.

I wonder how the rigidity holds up over time. Working at a robotics company, the mechanical engineers had to overcome quite some challenges to find a compromise between, precision, speed and repeatability.

And that was with a metal frame.

Re: PAROL6 Desktop Robot Arm

#5
I wonder how this compares to the AR4 robotic arm ( https://www.anninrobotics.com ). The AR4 isn't truly hardware open source, but my understanding is that it's software agnostic.

My biggest question is the full cost for the PAROL6. Their BOM link is 404.

I can build the AR4 completely for less than $2000, and for education, that's a very small price for a semi-useful, full 6 axis arm. (Currently, to give a comparison, one of my suppliers is offering an educational cobot solution for $40,000. Yes, it's truly "industrial," and is a complete self-contained solution, though it's only capable of 2kg if I recall correctly. This was what they were pushing for the educational market.)

As someone who is trying to implement robotic training in education, with a budget that approaches zero, I just need something cheap that students can hack/break/fix without costing a fortune in maintenance costs.

One of the cool thing about the AR4 is that it can come as a complete kit, either as 3d printable or aluminum frame. and they work with Steppers Online to provide the steppers and drivers as one package. If you work for a school system, this type of solution solves a lot of logistical issues.

That said, if this thing is truly low cost, let's say under $1000, for it's capabilities, it could be a very nice project.

Re: PAROL6 Desktop Robot Arm

#6
post #5

I wonder how this compares to the AR4 robotic arm ( https://www.anninrobotics.com ). The AR4 isn't truly hardware open source, but my understanding is that it's software agnostic. My biggest question is the full cost for the PAROL6. Their BOM link is 404. I can build the AR4 completely for less than $2000, and for education, that's a very small price for a semi-useful, full 6 axis arm. (Currently, to give a compariso…

The BOM file is in the repo I think: https://github.com/PCrnjak/PAROL6-Desktop-robot-arm/blob/mai...

Looks like they forgot to update the link.

Re: PAROL6 Desktop Robot Arm

#7

Interesting project. I wonder how the rigidity holds up over time. Working at a robotics company, the mechanical engineers had to overcome quite some challenges to find a compromise between, precision, speed and repeatability. And that was with a metal frame.

I imagine a lot of that will have to do with the 3d printed material used. If you're talking typical FDM style PLA, ABS, the creep on these can be pretty terrible.

If you're talking something like carbon fiber reinforced nylon, it's probably a bit better. If you move to something like Markforged's fiber-strand reinforcement it'd get even better. And then there are the SLA/SLS solutions, like Formlabs "rigid" material, which I think would be a very interesting material to try for this.

I think at the end of the day, you need to keep in mind this is an educational robot, not an industrial robot. If it can maintain 0.050" of repeatability, that would probably be good enough for a lot of use cases (but of course, that depends on your use case.)

Re: PAROL6 Desktop Robot Arm

#8
The instructions detail everything including the exact screws/nuts needed. EXCEPT the most important parts, the actual motors! It doesn't give any specs or names or a thing for those. Incredible.

Also the BOM info is gone.

Re: PAROL6 Desktop Robot Arm

#9
post #5

I wonder how this compares to the AR4 robotic arm ( https://www.anninrobotics.com ). The AR4 isn't truly hardware open source, but my understanding is that it's software agnostic. My biggest question is the full cost for the PAROL6. Their BOM link is 404. I can build the AR4 completely for less than $2000, and for education, that's a very small price for a semi-useful, full 6 axis arm. (Currently, to give a compariso…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN