Live data from Hacker News

Button Pushes You (2022)

despens.systems

1–10 of 43 posts

Re: Button Pushes You (2022)

#2
Gosh, yes, I find this style of obtuse labeling of buttons to be really annoying. It's especially prevalent when you're trying to get to API docs on some new framework you're checking out. Like, don't tell me I want to get started. Take me to the docs so I can decide if it's worth my time.

On reflection, this progression from function to call to action to obfuscated self-help-ish verbiage seems more like a general trend in marketing at all levels. Obviously, it must work in A/B testing, but I'm not sure it works in the general case. Here in the 2020s I think it serves as a kind of regurgitation of 1960s argle-bargle that's a callback to what's embedded in the brains of the children of boomers who picked up their parents' linguistic preference for out-there-isms to describe sensations of freedom from the old rigid hierarchies of the 1950s. So it's an appeal to nostalgia as much as a form of vaguely insulting corporate-speak.

Re: Button Pushes You (2022)

#6
I don't buy the politically laden, existentially fraught spin being sold here....

"Users have to accept the spelled out mantra and change their attitude before accessing the next piece of information."

"The user should transform themselves into a “doer,” rather than being considerate, evaluating options"

"Before proceeding, users should identify with this new aristocratic class."

C'mon. It's just a way to visually emphasize an important next step.

Is the text sometimes self-indulgent and annoying? Yeah, it's marketing copy. That's nothing new.

Re: Button Pushes You (2022)

#7
post #6

I don't buy the politically laden, existentially fraught spin being sold here.... "Users have to accept the spelled out mantra and change their attitude before accessing the next piece of information." "The user should transform themselves into a “doer,” rather than being considerate, evaluating options" "Before proceeding, users should identify with this new aristocratic class." C'mon. It's just a way to visually em…

It's infantilizing, though. Compared with marketing copy of old. Much of which can just be laid at the feet of a corporate nanny state that infantilizes everyone. Which is ultimately a political point.

Re: Button Pushes You (2022)

#8
Ah yes. This is one of the marvels of having browser APIs that want to give you (almost) complete control over the machine, and let you do (almost) anything...

Upside: You can do almost anything.

Downside: You have to manage (almost) everything yourself.

Downside: It lets other people do real dumb/annoying/inconvenient/stupid things, and you get to deal with the result.

Re: Button Pushes You (2022)

#9
post #2

Gosh, yes, I find this style of obtuse labeling of buttons to be really annoying. It's especially prevalent when you're trying to get to API docs on some new framework you're checking out. Like, don't tell me I want to get started. Take me to the docs so I can decide if it's worth my time. On reflection, this progression from function to call to action to obfuscated self-help-ish verbiage seems more like a general tr…

Might be a tangent but trying to do end of tax year stuff when each service hides stuff like invoices behind screens of these kinds of buttons. Godaddy is horrendous: I think I had to click domain.name, manage, taken to a screen upselling me hosting them find some settings, click account, click my domain name again then something else then you get a list of invoices. On the plus side they exist! (as opposed to Amazon third party sellers) and a simple PDF download from there.

Re: Button Pushes You (2022)

#10
post #4

Slightly off topic, but I love the way that blog design uses the right gutter for annotations. Keeps it in context beautifully.

Best migration of foot notes to the web (though the ones that pop up a banner as a sort of ur tool-tip, or expand into a bubble when clicked on are also decent). Most "footnotes" on webpages are actually end-notes, which is mostly a consequence of the lack of distinct pages. Fitting that a blog seemingly about design gets this right.
Post reply on HN