Google (translate) is stupid - NOT • Hacker News Board

Google (translate) is stupid - NOT

#1

Post by mrpixel » Wed, Mar 07, 2012, 4:07 PM UTC

Google (translate) is stupid - NOT
translate.google.com

Re: Google (translate) is stupid - NOT

#2

Post by mrpixel » Wed, Mar 07, 2012, 4:09 PM UTC

For you non-German speakers out there "google ist doof" actually says that Google IS stupid. It doesn't happen with a capital G, though.

Re: Google (translate) is stupid - NOT

#3

Post by dangrossman » Wed, Mar 07, 2012, 5:13 PM UTC

I've seen other examples of obviously wrong translations a machine wouldn't come up with -- there must be a feedback mechanism somewhere that people (non-employees) can provide a translation, and some people abusing it.

Re: Google (translate) is stupid - NOT

#4

Post by cobrausn » Wed, Mar 07, 2012, 5:14 PM UTC

mrpixel wrote: post #2

For you non-German speakers out there "google ist doof" actually says that Google IS stupid. It doesn't happen with a capital G, though.

If you go the opposite direction (English -> German), the translation doesn't exhibit the negation that the German -> English translation does.

http://translate.google.com/#en|de|google%20is%20stupid%0A

Re: Google (translate) is stupid - NOT

#5

Post by th0ma5 » Wed, Mar 07, 2012, 5:19 PM UTC

dangrossman wrote: post #3

I've seen other examples of obviously wrong translations a machine wouldn't come up with -- there must be a feedback mechanism somewhere that people (non-employees) can provide a translation, and some people abusing it.

Yes in the Stanford AI class they talked about the feedback mechanisms, and it is mixed with the automatic translations that come from comparative analysis of documents on the web that are already translated.

Re: Google (translate) is stupid - NOT

#6

Post by achompas » Wed, Mar 07, 2012, 5:22 PM UTC

Spanish is fine:

http://translate.google.com/#es|en|google%20es%20estupido

http://translate.google.com/#es|en|google%20es%20un%20estupi...

(the former translates to correct english, the latter is correct spanish)

Re: Google (translate) is stupid - NOT

#7

Post by cleverjake » Wed, Mar 07, 2012, 5:40 PM UTC

In case one is unaware, google's translation service is built upon 'high grade' translations - originally from UN translation logs. So, if you actually get a few hundred sites to provide incorrect translations for a specific phrase, you could theoretically game google translate in this manner.

Re: Google (translate) is stupid - NOT

#8

Post by bjxrn » Wed, Mar 07, 2012, 5:48 PM UTC

dangrossman wrote: post #3

I've seen other examples of obviously wrong translations a machine wouldn't come up with -- there must be a feedback mechanism somewhere that people (non-employees) can provide a translation, and some people abusing it.

I thought this was widely known but when you hover over translated text, whether this is on the Google Translate page, or at a translated site, you get the option to correct the translated text if you want.

I don't know if this has always been the case, but I'm pretty sure it's been around for a few years.