Live data from Hacker News

Thumb-Key: A privacy-conscious Android keyboard, made for your thumbs

github.com

1–10 of 39 posts

Re: Thumb-Key: A privacy-conscious Android keyboard, made for your thumbs

#2
Neat idea, shame about all this misleading information though.

The website very strongly implies (1) the only way to predict words is by uploading every keystroke to central server,(2) every keyboard other than theirs do that and (3) the only way to get privacy is to download their product.

This is all complete lies of course. The prediction database is small enough that you can bundle it with app and run all prediction locally. The "upload each keystroke" part is completely optional -- some keyboards have no such functionality, and some keyboards require explicit opt-it via the easily findable checkbox.

It's a pity that the authors of such original ideas have to resort to lies to promote their product.

Re: Thumb-Key: A privacy-conscious Android keyboard, made for your thumbs

#5
For the love of god... just show me how it works. Yes, based on a previous product. Yes, privacy is nice. Highly configurable. History of phone keyboards...

"Tap, or slide / swipe to type a letter." Slide/swipe how? "Swipe up or down on A to capitalize." So is A acting like a shift key? Or is that for every letter? How to capitalize the letters then that I somehow have to slide/swipe on?

Show me how it is working.

Re: Thumb-Key: A privacy-conscious Android keyboard, made for your thumbs

#7
That's awesome

It would be nice to add more messagease layouts, multitouch 2-pane mode, more symbols, and layout customization features.

Lack of question mark in the standard layout drives me mad.

Also it would be good to have an option to disable animations, they are extremely distracting.

Re: Thumb-Key: A privacy-conscious Android keyboard, made for your thumbs

#9
post #2

Neat idea, shame about all this misleading information though. The website very strongly implies (1) the only way to predict words is by uploading every keystroke to central server,(2) every keyboard other than theirs do that and (3) the only way to get privacy is to download their product. This is all complete lies of course. The prediction database is small enough that you can bundle it with app and run all predict…

A keyboard shouldn't have network permission at all.

Re: Thumb-Key: A privacy-conscious Android keyboard, made for your thumbs

#10
post #2

Neat idea, shame about all this misleading information though. The website very strongly implies (1) the only way to predict words is by uploading every keystroke to central server,(2) every keyboard other than theirs do that and (3) the only way to get privacy is to download their product. This is all complete lies of course. The prediction database is small enough that you can bundle it with app and run all predict…

A keyboard shouldn't have network permission at all.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN