Live data from Hacker News

Locally run a ChatGPT-style LLM Trained from 800k GPT-3.5-Turbo Generations

twitter.com

1–9 of 9 posts

Re: Locally run a ChatGPT-style LLM Trained from 800k GPT-3.5-Turbo Generations

#2
I can’t wait for “competing with OpenAI” to get more clearly defined.

For example, could I use ChatGPT to create training data for a (non-llama) language model that I then sell per-device licenses to end users? OpenAI doesn’t sell per-device licenses, so I wouldn’t be competing with them.

Right?

Re: Locally run a ChatGPT-style LLM Trained from 800k GPT-3.5-Turbo Generations

#4
Not exactly seeing great performance with this model. It gets tripped up by ridiculously silly questions.

For example "if you have a spoon, a knife, a fork, a carrot and a calculator, which one would you use for math?"

> None. The question is grammatically incorrect as it implies that the person has all of those items in their possession at once

or

"The bus was going so fast it passed the racecar". What vehicle was going the fastest?"

> It's impossible to tell which one went faster, as they were both traveling at high speeds

Re: Locally run a ChatGPT-style LLM Trained from 800k GPT-3.5-Turbo Generations

#5
post #4

Not exactly seeing great performance with this model. It gets tripped up by ridiculously silly questions. For example "if you have a spoon, a knife, a fork, a carrot and a calculator, which one would you use for math?" > None. The question is grammatically incorrect as it implies that the person has all of those items in their possession at once or "The bus was going so fast it passed the racecar". What vehicle was g…

ChatGPT and Claude also get tripped by both questions

Re: Locally run a ChatGPT-style LLM Trained from 800k GPT-3.5-Turbo Generations

#6
post #4

Not exactly seeing great performance with this model. It gets tripped up by ridiculously silly questions. For example "if you have a spoon, a knife, a fork, a carrot and a calculator, which one would you use for math?" > None. The question is grammatically incorrect as it implies that the person has all of those items in their possession at once or "The bus was going so fast it passed the racecar". What vehicle was g…

yeah, gonna need a few more M's of data work for that unfortunately.

Re: Locally run a ChatGPT-style LLM Trained from 800k GPT-3.5-Turbo Generations

#7
post #5
post #4

Not exactly seeing great performance with this model. It gets tripped up by ridiculously silly questions. For example "if you have a spoon, a knife, a fork, a carrot and a calculator, which one would you use for math?" > None. The question is grammatically incorrect as it implies that the person has all of those items in their possession at once or "The bus was going so fast it passed the racecar". What vehicle was g…

ChatGPT and Claude also get tripped by both questions

GPT-4 (Bing) solves them correctly.

Re: Locally run a ChatGPT-style LLM Trained from 800k GPT-3.5-Turbo Generations

#8
post #5
post #4

Not exactly seeing great performance with this model. It gets tripped up by ridiculously silly questions. For example "if you have a spoon, a knife, a fork, a carrot and a calculator, which one would you use for math?" > None. The question is grammatically incorrect as it implies that the person has all of those items in their possession at once or "The bus was going so fast it passed the racecar". What vehicle was g…

ChatGPT and Claude also get tripped by both questions

I think Claude is correct on the merits (Claude’s awesome in general)

Without more context about the speeds of the bus and racecar, I cannot determine which vehicle was going fastest based on the given statement. Simply saying that the bus passed the racecar does not provide enough information to compare their speeds.

Re: Locally run a ChatGPT-style LLM Trained from 800k GPT-3.5-Turbo Generations

#9
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

ChatGPT and Claude also get tripped by both questions

I think Claude is correct on the merits (Claude’s awesome in general) Without more context about the speeds of the bus and racecar, I cannot determine which vehicle was going fastest based on the given statement. Simply saying that the bus passed the racecar does not provide enough information to compare their speeds.

This is true, the question isn't inconsistent with the bus and the racecar travelling in opposite directions, it's just implied that they're going in the same direction.