Live data from Hacker News

Lidar Reveals 650-Square-Mile Maya Site Hidden Beneath Guatemalan Rain Forest

livescience.com

1–10 of 59 posts

Re: Lidar Reveals 650-Square-Mile Maya Site Hidden Beneath Guatemalan Rain Forest

#6

This is exciting as someone who recently discovered Graham Hancock.

What is exciting about Graham Hancock an easily debunked promoter of pseudoscientific theories? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graham_Hancock

Re: Lidar Reveals 650-Square-Mile Maya Site Hidden Beneath Guatemalan Rain Forest

#8

This is exciting as someone who recently discovered Graham Hancock.

What is exciting about Graham Hancock an easily debunked promoter of pseudoscientific theories? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graham_Hancock

He stimulates my imagination to propose even more fantastic "what if" scenarios. The Wikipedian, "Objective truth derives from quotable CNN articles and talk page bickering" not only misses the point, but is problematic epistemologically.

Re: Lidar Reveals 650-Square-Mile Maya Site Hidden Beneath Guatemalan Rain Forest

#9

This is exciting as someone who recently discovered Graham Hancock.

What is exciting about Graham Hancock an easily debunked promoter of pseudoscientific theories? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graham_Hancock

Graham Hancock is a journalist and a compelling science communicator. He has pursued theories outside the orthodox views of conventional archeology and, at least with the younger Dryas impact hypothesis, more and more evidence points to the fact that he may be right and conventional archeology may be wrong.

Smearing him as a promoter of pseudo-scientific theories without articulating your rationale is frankly weak-sauce.

I find your argument as un-compelling as those who smear others as conspiracy theorists so they can dismiss their claims without a second thought. Try harder.

Re: Lidar Reveals 650-Square-Mile Maya Site Hidden Beneath Guatemalan Rain Forest

#10
post #5

what kind of lasers / lidar technology is this that is not reflected by trees?

Good question!

According to [1], they rely on finding holmes in the foliage:

Lidar, of course, does not actually see through vegetation. Rather, it sees through holes in the foliage. Some of the multiple laser pulses it emits simply find openings between leaves and branches, in much the same way that sunlight filters through the forest canopy, continuing down to the ground.

[1]: https://www.gislounge.com/next-generation-lidar-seeing-the-f....

Post reply on HN