Live data from Hacker News

Jailbreaking Is Not A Crime

jailbreakingisnotacrime.org

1–10 of 59 posts

Re: Jailbreaking Is Not A Crime

#2
In theory, I agree. In practice, I've realized that most of the jailbreaking phones/tablets are used to download illegal applications and/or without paying. I know this is a somewhat contrived statement, but this is from what I've seen in company/university/engineering departments I've worked/studied.

Note:

I myself had to jailbreak my iphone to install spotify (and asked a friend to pay for it since he's outside of Canada). For some reasons, spotify is illegal here. (Yes, I know, I illegally downloaded an illegal application to legally download/listen to music).

Re: Jailbreaking Is Not A Crime

#3
post #2

In theory, I agree. In practice, I've realized that most of the jailbreaking phones/tablets are used to download illegal applications and/or without paying. I know this is a somewhat contrived statement, but this is from what I've seen in company/university/engineering departments I've worked/studied. Note: I myself had to jailbreak my iphone to install spotify (and asked a friend to pay for it since he's outside of…

Even if 100% of the uses were illegal, this is an issue of principal. When I buy a gadget, I didn't lease it, I bought it. It is mine. As such, I shouldn't have to worry I might go to jail (!!) for modifying my device in a way that doesn't impact anybody else.

Re: Jailbreaking Is Not A Crime

#4
post #2

In theory, I agree. In practice, I've realized that most of the jailbreaking phones/tablets are used to download illegal applications and/or without paying. I know this is a somewhat contrived statement, but this is from what I've seen in company/university/engineering departments I've worked/studied. Note: I myself had to jailbreak my iphone to install spotify (and asked a friend to pay for it since he's outside of…

Very few of the applications available on Cydia are "illegal", they're just banned from the App Store by Apple. Similarly, there's nothing illegal about linux, but you'll have to jailbreak your ps3 to install it.

Re: Jailbreaking Is Not A Crime

#5
post #2

In theory, I agree. In practice, I've realized that most of the jailbreaking phones/tablets are used to download illegal applications and/or without paying. I know this is a somewhat contrived statement, but this is from what I've seen in company/university/engineering departments I've worked/studied. Note: I myself had to jailbreak my iphone to install spotify (and asked a friend to pay for it since he's outside of…

I used a jailbroken iPhone for 2 years, I never once pirated an application, I still purchased plenty of apps from Apple's dumb app store and a few from Cydia. Mostly, I just used it to "background" apps before that was a built-in feature.

Re: Jailbreaking Is Not A Crime

#6
This is a basic freedom issue. The freedom to run software I control on devices I own allows me to be free in how I share and protect my own private information. Apple and Microsoft are trending toward making it more difficult and less legal to run alternative operating systems or unapproved 3rd party software on their platforms. It has to be fought tooth and nail. Fight it legally, and fight it with your pocketbook.

Re: Jailbreaking Is Not A Crime

#7
post #2

In theory, I agree. In practice, I've realized that most of the jailbreaking phones/tablets are used to download illegal applications and/or without paying. I know this is a somewhat contrived statement, but this is from what I've seen in company/university/engineering departments I've worked/studied. Note: I myself had to jailbreak my iphone to install spotify (and asked a friend to pay for it since he's outside of…

> illegally downloaded an illegal application to legally download/listen to music

You mean to _illegally_ download/listen to music; there's no license in your region.

Re: Jailbreaking Is Not A Crime

#8
post #2

In theory, I agree. In practice, I've realized that most of the jailbreaking phones/tablets are used to download illegal applications and/or without paying. I know this is a somewhat contrived statement, but this is from what I've seen in company/university/engineering departments I've worked/studied. Note: I myself had to jailbreak my iphone to install spotify (and asked a friend to pay for it since he's outside of…

Most cars with performance tuning are used to speed on roads, but it should be and is still legal.

Re: Jailbreaking Is Not A Crime

#9
My jail is CIA or something. Fucken evil parents are CIA.

God says... C:\LoseThos\www.losethos.com\text\YANKEE.TXT

eagerly together, that the knight of the turret was soon smitten down, horse and man, stark dead--"

"_Another_ horse gone; I tell you it is a custom that ought to be broken up. I don't see how people with any feeling can applaud and support it."

    .   .   .   .
"So these two knights came together with great random--"

I saw that I had been asleep and missed a chapter, but I didn't say anything. I judged that the Irish knight was in trouble with the visitors by this time, and this turned

Re: Jailbreaking Is Not A Crime

#10

This is a basic freedom issue. The freedom to run software I control on devices I own allows me to be free in how I share and protect my own private information. Apple and Microsoft are trending toward making it more difficult and less legal to run alternative operating systems or unapproved 3rd party software on their platforms. It has to be fought tooth and nail. Fight it legally, and fight it with your pocketbook.

Your freedom to own your smart phone will disappear eventually when Hollywood figures out you didn't actually buy your phone, you are paying a monthly service which pays down your phone, an unspecified price. A percentage of which should go straight to Hollywood.
Post reply on HN