Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Will AI put programmers our of work?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 117 posts

Ask HN: Will AI put programmers our of work?

#1
There's a lot of news regarding copilot and openAI and what have you. I'm not familiar with AI so I cannot really tell hype from substance here.

Should I worry? Do you think that some form of AI will be able to do the job of an average programmer any time soon? If yes what is your estimate? And how would you try to AI-proof your career?

Re: Ask HN: Will AI put programmers our of work?

#2
It's hard to predict the future.

One aspect that's being slighly neglected is that programming isn't that special - tools like ChatGPT can potentially impact any kind of knowledge work. So it's not like there's a safe white-collar career track that you can easily move to.

Re: Ask HN: Will AI put programmers our of work?

#5
Funnily enough I was just asking chatGPT what it thought about it, so here it goes:

>It is unlikely that AI will completely replace programmers. While AI and machine learning technology has advanced significantly in recent years, there are still many tasks that require human creativity and intuition, such as coming up with new ideas, solving complex problems, and making decisions that involve subjective judgement. Additionally, as AI and machine learning technology continues to advance, it is likely that new job opportunities will be created in fields related to these technologies, such as developing and managing AI systems.

Re: Ask HN: Will AI put programmers our of work?

#6

Funnily enough I was just asking chatGPT what it thought about it, so here it goes: >It is unlikely that AI will completely replace programmers. While AI and machine learning technology has advanced significantly in recent years, there are still many tasks that require human creativity and intuition, such as coming up with new ideas, solving complex problems, and making decisions that involve subjective judgement. Ad…

Altering the prompt a bit (how will AI put programmers out of work?)

>It is unlikely that AI will completely put programmers out of work. However, it is possible that certain tasks currently performed by programmers, such as routine and repetitive tasks, could be automated by AI in the future. This could potentially lead to job displacement for some programmers. It is also possible that the increasing use of AI could lead to a shift in the types of skills and expertise that are in demand in the job market, potentially making some programming skills and knowledge less valuable. However, as AI and machine learning technology continue to evolve, it is likely that new job opportunities will be created in fields related to these technologies, such as developing and managing AI systems.

Re: Ask HN: Will AI put programmers our of work?

#8
I wonder if AI can do something like, here is a new programming language that has been written which provides better error handling and concurrency. Anyways, its the hot buzz now and everyone is using it. So do this for me, here is the source code of the language and its documentation.

Understand all that and create an app for me that does the work X.

Re: Ask HN: Will AI put programmers our of work?

#9
>Do you think that some form of AI will be able to do the job of an average programmer any time soon?

No. AI is not a greater threat than stack overflow.

The skills of a programmer are not generating 20 lines of code to solve a well known problem. And even a 99% AI is next to useless, since finding errors is exceedingly hard.

Re: Ask HN: Will AI put programmers our of work?

#10
If AI technology continues to advance and is able to take over most jobs, it will fundamentally change the way society functions.

In a capitalist economy, people are expected to work hard in order to produce goods and services, which drives economic growth. But if AI can do all of the work, there may be no need for people to work at all.

This could lead to a new economic model, one where prosperity is not tied to the labor of individuals. Instead, the focus could shift to ensuring that everyone has access to the resources and opportunities they need to thrive, regardless of whether they are working or not.

Post reply on HN