Live data from Hacker News

Metallica Concerts, 1982-2012 [Infographics]

cilekagaci.com

1–10 of 41 posts

Metallica Concerts, 1982-2012 [Infographics]

#1
"This is an examination of Metallica’s concert history from 1982 to 2012 with a focus on the numbers of songs played live and the albums that they belong to. We took the raw data from Setlist.fm (plus Last.fm in the last part), groomed it and visualized it with our own tools."

Metallica Concerts, 1982-2012 [Infographics]
cilekagaci.com

Re: Metallica Concerts, 1982-2012 [Infographics]

#5
This is pretty cool.

A few interesting observations:

1. Metallica seems to have realized themselves that St Anger wasn't something they wanted to play after that tour. The Load album seems to have been similarly dropped pretty hard.

2. It appears they never even tried playing the majority of Reload live. This is interesting to me as a musician, because I'd have thought that Metallica would be the type of band to try a lot of their songs live before recording them, but it doesn't seem to be the case.

3. Very shocked that they never played Unforgiven II live, since it was a single and everything.

4. I really liked the Audience vs Band chart.

Re: Metallica Concerts, 1982-2012 [Infographics]

#6

I am so glad that some people have a lot of time on their hands. This is awesome.

I know! Now, imagine if those same people also had good taste in music... That would be so cool!

Clearly they do, because they were smart enough to know that Load and everything from there until Death Magnetic should be looked at separately, since it sucked. But yes, I need to see a Tool version of this immediately.

Re: Metallica Concerts, 1982-2012 [Infographics]

#7
This is great, but the low contrast between the text and the background makes it very hard to read.

With no evidence I feel that this is something of a trend at the moment; I've recently battled our designers when they have sacrificed readability.

I'm 29 and have excellent vision, I can't imagine how hard this could be to read for people who don't.

Re: Metallica Concerts, 1982-2012 [Infographics]

#8
Cool idea, but I'm going to quibble a bit on the Audience vs. Band Chart. Suppose for simplicity that a band has four songs A, B, C, and D that respectively 40% 20% 20% and 20% of people would prefer to hear at a concert. Now suppose the band can only play one song.

Which song should they play?

I don't think the answer to that question is a random mix of the songs with 40% song A, I think the answer is 100% song A. If you play any of the other songs, you make 20% of the audience happy, if you play A you make 40% happy, it strictly dominates. In other words, I don't think playing the songs at a concert in proportion to their last.fm statistics makes sense since at home listeners have as much time as they want but concert time is a limited resource that should be used on the best songs.

So I would be interested in the rank order of listening stats vs. rank order of concert songs and look for anomalies. Unforgiven (I, II, III?) are probably going to make that list since I've actually heard of that one and I am definitely not a Metallica fan.

Re: Metallica Concerts, 1982-2012 [Infographics]

#9
post #5

This is pretty cool. A few interesting observations: 1. Metallica seems to have realized themselves that St Anger wasn't something they wanted to play after that tour. The Load album seems to have been similarly dropped pretty hard. 2. It appears they never even tried playing the majority of Reload live. This is interesting to me as a musician, because I'd have thought that Metallica would be the type of band to try…

Am I only the person ever to like Load? I know it's not their best, but I still enjoyed it.

Re: Metallica Concerts, 1982-2012 [Infographics]

#10
post #5

This is pretty cool. A few interesting observations: 1. Metallica seems to have realized themselves that St Anger wasn't something they wanted to play after that tour. The Load album seems to have been similarly dropped pretty hard. 2. It appears they never even tried playing the majority of Reload live. This is interesting to me as a musician, because I'd have thought that Metallica would be the type of band to try…

They've played Unforgiven II once live. Check the graphic again. I think the video is on youtube.

In general, they didn't play new stuff live.

Here's to hoping they play fixxxer live one day.

Post reply on HN