YapDi - Yet another python Daemon implementation
1–6 of 6 posts
Re: YapDi - Yet another python Daemon implementation
#2Having written a specialized daemon library for PHP, my take is that this seems clean, but unless you need special functionality, I really prefer a while(true) and supervisord.
In my case (https://github.com/shaneharter/PHP-Daemon) a project needed a way to run code on a timer every second. For more basic cases supervisord or similar is the way I'd go.
And no, I wouldn't suggest that anybody write daemons in PHP. It's one of those things that was the best of several bad options. Python is a bit better, but if I had my choice it would be in a language that had real threading.
Re: YapDi - Yet another python Daemon implementation
#3Daemonization is really something that ought to be done outside the process being daemonized, a la supervisord or (if you prefer Python) something like my own project, finitd[0]. Unless you have something you must do as root before dropping privileges, leave daemonization to a separate, purpose-built program like these. It's the UNIX way.
Re: YapDi - Yet another python Daemon implementation
#4Daemonization is really something that ought to be done outside the process being daemonized, a la supervisord or (if you prefer Python) something like my own project, finitd[0]. Unless you have something you must do as root before dropping privileges, leave daemonization to a separate, purpose-built program like these. It's the UNIX way. [0] https://github.com/jemfinch/finitd
I don't really understand how it would matter to a user, but you do know supervisord is written in python as well right?
Re: YapDi - Yet another python Daemon implementation
#5Daemonization is really something that ought to be done outside the process being daemonized, a la supervisord or (if you prefer Python) something like my own project, finitd[0]. Unless you have something you must do as root before dropping privileges, leave daemonization to a separate, purpose-built program like these. It's the UNIX way. [0] https://github.com/jemfinch/finitd
I don't really understand how it would matter to a user, but you do know supervisord is written in python as well right?
Ah, no. I was actually thinking of DJB's daemontools, but had supervisord on the mind because it was mentioned elsewhere in this thread.
Re: YapDi - Yet another python Daemon implementation
#6Interesting, potentially useful.
It seems a little sad to me that Twisted is so unappreciated; it solved many current problems a long time ago, including very good deamonizing.