Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Getting HOA to upgrade Ethernet wiring

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 22 posts

Ask HN: Getting HOA to upgrade Ethernet wiring

#1
Hi HN,

I naively purchased a condo that said it had google fiber.

Unfortunately, the building is wired with CAT5 and limits out at 100 megabytes.

I’ve reached out to my HOA to advocate for an upgrade of each units wiring so we can take full advantage of the fiber connection.

Has anyone gone through something like this in the past?

How would you advise I attempt to get folks on board?

Thanks in advance!

Re: Ask HN: Getting HOA to upgrade Ethernet wiring

#2
Is there anything blocking you from upgrading only your unit's connection?

You'd generally need a permission from other owners for any work in the hallways and such, but as long as the disruption is not too bad, and nothing is coming out of their pocket, you probably won't have much issue.

Re: Ask HN: Getting HOA to upgrade Ethernet wiring

#3
post #2

Is there anything blocking you from upgrading only your unit's connection? You'd generally need a permission from other owners for any work in the hallways and such, but as long as the disruption is not too bad, and nothing is coming out of their pocket, you probably won't have much issue.

That is a great point! Hopefully it is that easy and I’m over thinking it. Thanks for the suggestion :)

Re: Ask HN: Getting HOA to upgrade Ethernet wiring

#4
You may have better luck with a wireless setup, as it wouldn't require cutting into anyone's walls. It would also be less expensive.

You would need pro-grade equipment, but the high-end stuff won't have trouble approaching Google Fiber speeds.

Re: Ask HN: Getting HOA to upgrade Ethernet wiring

#5
Cost is the major consideration. If the Cat5 cable was installed during construction, it might be very difficult to pull in replacement cabling. The labor and associated management, administration costs rapidly mount up. Unless a significant proportion of owners want the same, you might be better off seeing if you can simply upgrade your unit's connection. Even that might involve new conduits, etc which you might need to get professionally installed.

Re: Ask HN: Getting HOA to upgrade Ethernet wiring

#8
post #2

Is there anything blocking you from upgrading only your unit's connection? You'd generally need a permission from other owners for any work in the hallways and such, but as long as the disruption is not too bad, and nothing is coming out of their pocket, you probably won't have much issue.

That is a great point! Hopefully it is that easy and I’m over thinking it. Thanks for the suggestion :)

Check that all 4 pairs of wires in the Ethernet cable are connected at both ends. CondoInternet had a number of cat5 buildings where they had only connected two pairs and simply recrimping the Ethernet connector got you gigabit.

Syncing at gigabit on Cat5 is common, even if a spec sheet says it's not l.

Post reply on HN