Live data from Hacker News

Carmakers feel chip crisis easing

bloomberg.com

1–10 of 261 posts

Re: Carmakers feel chip crisis easing

#2
I saw an article recently saying that dealerships and car makers want to keep inventories low because they like the post-covid margins they're experiencing. When I paid 5k over msrp a few months ago the salesperson claimed they wanted more inventory because salespeople were unable to hit the volume goals they have. Not sure who to believe but I'm sure the truth lies somewhere in between.

Re: Carmakers feel chip crisis easing

#5

I saw an article recently saying that dealerships and car makers want to keep inventories low because they like the post-covid margins they're experiencing. When I paid 5k over msrp a few months ago the salesperson claimed they wanted more inventory because salespeople were unable to hit the volume goals they have. Not sure who to believe but I'm sure the truth lies somewhere in between.

I'm sure they will all return to the way they did things prior to covid. All it will take is GM or Ford to start stacking new vehicles on car lots, and all of them will have to follow along.

Re: Carmakers feel chip crisis easing

#6

I saw an article recently saying that dealerships and car makers want to keep inventories low because they like the post-covid margins they're experiencing. When I paid 5k over msrp a few months ago the salesperson claimed they wanted more inventory because salespeople were unable to hit the volume goals they have. Not sure who to believe but I'm sure the truth lies somewhere in between.

Really glad that dealers in Canada can't charge over MSRP for new vehicles.

Re: Carmakers feel chip crisis easing

#8

I saw an article recently saying that dealerships and car makers want to keep inventories low because they like the post-covid margins they're experiencing. When I paid 5k over msrp a few months ago the salesperson claimed they wanted more inventory because salespeople were unable to hit the volume goals they have. Not sure who to believe but I'm sure the truth lies somewhere in between.

Disclosure: I work for GM. Anything expressed here is solely my own opinion and experience.

I think each statement is true.

Context: for ages, OEMs (the factory) have had a belief that Americans will not wait to buy a car. There's also a bit of a prisoner's dilemma: if any automaker wanted to trim inventories, the customer could go to a competing automaker's lot and buy today. Since customers will not wait to buy a car, a dealership must have some quantity of vehicles that are acceptable to buy today.

Now customers are used to waiting and nothing really catastrophic happened to the dealer or the OEM. In fact profits went up substantially. If OEMs or dealers had worked together to limit inventory, that would be illegal market manipulation. (I'm sure someone may build a conspiracy theory out of this, but I do not believe any intentional market manipulation took place).

Dealerships hate carrying extra inventory because it costs money to finance the vehicles until they sell them.

However, there are also salesperson and dealership bonuses based on volume, so that individual salesperson is feeling the pinch. Kind of similar to how crazy home prices are right now (in many large cities) - the homebuyer is hurting, but the real estate agents aren't making a commensurate amount of extra money because the market is relatively inelastic.

In future American OEMs may move to a more European model where vehicles are built to specific customer order. This takes on the order of two months at the moment for many legacy reasons, but there is no need for it to actually take this long.

Re: Carmakers feel chip crisis easing

#9
post #3

I'm still 6-8 months out for a Toyota van

I ordered a new Porsche SUV in the middle of December. It just got offloaded from the ship at port today, so I should finally have it in a couple weeks. But it will be missing some of the electronics, such as the electric steering wheel adjustment due to chip shortages.

My poor sister-in-law also thought she ordered a Toyota in December. But as it turns out, the dealership just took advantage of her and told her they ordered her a car when really she gave the dealership a $500 deposit to let her know if a car ever comes in that matches what she wanted.

Post reply on HN