Live data from Hacker News

Fuck Your Miracle Year

rogersbacon.substack.com

1–10 of 169 posts

Re: Fuck Your Miracle Year

#2
> I agree with Dwarkesh that we should be doing more to help young people have miracle years

Optimizing any system for "geniuses" seems very silly to me.

> Look, no one talked about how we can engineer miracle years when miracle years were actually still happening. This modern obsession with progress is just a sign of our decadence, of our creative exhaustion and inability to innovate in any meaningful way.

I'm reading this mega-tome about the guilded age right now and I promise you this is not true.

Re: Fuck Your Miracle Year

#3
This is a really weird article. Of course VC people and bloggers are not going to have miracle years - the people with the potential to make amazing discoveries have much better things to do then talk about how to get other people to make amazing discoveries. The hope of an article like Miracle Years is that someone in power makes a change to a school policy or something like that and makes it more likely for someone else to have a miracle year.

Re: Fuck Your Miracle Year

#4

> I agree with Dwarkesh that we should be doing more to help young people have miracle years Optimizing any system for "geniuses" seems very silly to me. > Look, no one talked about how we can engineer miracle years when miracle years were actually still happening. This modern obsession with progress is just a sign of our decadence, of our creative exhaustion and inability to innovate in any meaningful way. I'm readi…

> mega-tome about the guilded age

What's the title? Sounds interesting.

Re: Fuck Your Miracle Year

#6
> Because now people have to spend their 20s learning about the discoveries that others made during their miracle years (the so-called “burden of knowledge”).

Maybe now people have to spend their 20s learning about the discoveries because our modern pre-post-secondary education has become so watered down and unambitious.

Personally, I get the sense that could have learned 5x to 20x as much in my teenage years if I hadn't been in an excessively mediocre public education system. And I'm not a genius :)

Re: Fuck Your Miracle Year

#7

> I agree with Dwarkesh that we should be doing more to help young people have miracle years Optimizing any system for "geniuses" seems very silly to me. > Look, no one talked about how we can engineer miracle years when miracle years were actually still happening. This modern obsession with progress is just a sign of our decadence, of our creative exhaustion and inability to innovate in any meaningful way. I'm readi…

> mega-tome about the guilded age What's the title? Sounds interesting.

The Republic for Which It Stands - The United States during Reconstruction and the Gilded Age, 1865-1896

by Richard White

Re: Fuck Your Miracle Year

#10
post #6

> Because now people have to spend their 20s learning about the discoveries that others made during their miracle years (the so-called “burden of knowledge”). Maybe now people have to spend their 20s learning about the discoveries because our modern pre-post-secondary education has become so watered down and unambitious. Personally, I get the sense that could have learned 5x to 20x as much in my teenage years if I ha…

I remember how slowly high school math moved. How uninspired English class was. The poor curriculum and tools in programming class. imo, there is definitely a primary and secondary education problem vs. the early-life academic environments that helped to produce yesteryear's great thinkers.

https://erikhoel.substack.com/p/why-we-stopped-making-einste...

Post reply on HN