Live data from Hacker News

It’s Still Stupidly, Difficult to Buy a ‘Dumb’ TV

techdirt.com

1–10 of 434 posts

Re: It’s Still Stupidly, Difficult to Buy a ‘Dumb’ TV

#3

I’m dead serious I’d pay an $80 to $100 premium for a dumb TV I’d even consider replacing a couple Smart TVs are just terrible

The other day I was reading the HDMI spec. I realised, in almost full horror, it’s stupidly streaming pixels instead of image deltas. When every TV has memory enough for several full frame images, this is just crazy.

Re: It’s Still Stupidly, Difficult to Buy a ‘Dumb’ TV

#5

I’m dead serious I’d pay an $80 to $100 premium for a dumb TV I’d even consider replacing a couple Smart TVs are just terrible

I've switched to buy computer monitors since I realised I don't watch TV anymore. Even if I did there are more than one way to watch TV on non-TV devices over here (some free, some paid, some both, e.g the quite awesome molotov.tv, which gives a TV experience quite better than any smart TV)

Re: It’s Still Stupidly, Difficult to Buy a ‘Dumb’ TV

#8
post #7

Is there a reason I’m not aware of that not connecting a smart to to a network isn’t enough? Do they auto-connect to open Wi-Fi for example?

Apparently some(? many? most?) of them refuse to work at all until they've been "set up" over the internet. Don't know for sure though; I'm clinging to my old dumb TV like a life raft.

Re: It’s Still Stupidly, Difficult to Buy a ‘Dumb’ TV

#9
post #3

I’m dead serious I’d pay an $80 to $100 premium for a dumb TV I’d even consider replacing a couple Smart TVs are just terrible

The other day I was reading the HDMI spec. I realised, in almost full horror, it’s stupidly streaming pixels instead of image deltas. When every TV has memory enough for several full frame images, this is just crazy.

You're thinking of bandwidth savings?

Rethink that. If HDMI were delta-compressed, then what happens if you exceed the bandwidth limit for several frames in a row? To be reliable, it needs to have as much bandwidth allocated as is needed for bitmap streaming. And in that case, why not just stream the bitmaps...

Re: It’s Still Stupidly, Difficult to Buy a ‘Dumb’ TV

#10

Every TV is "stupid" when it's not connected to the internet, and none of them can transmit your data when disconnected.

If it turns out that too many people are disconnecting their tv, the manufacturer would merely add in a sim card.

They don't yet ATM because they don't need to - too many people are stupidly connecting their wifi.

Post reply on HN