Live data from Hacker News

Nuclear power may be the key to least-cost, zero-emission electricity systems

carnegiescience.edu

1–10 of 88 posts

Re: Nuclear power may be the key to least-cost, zero-emission electricity systems

#3
post #2

Why is it so hard to grasp: we don't want to trade our toxic carbon byproduct for toxic fission byproduct?

There must be some stable backup for renewables. Nuclear is not perfect, but it's the best by a long shot compared to anything else, according to statistics (including all disasters!).

Re: Nuclear power may be the key to least-cost, zero-emission electricity systems

#5
post #2

Why is it so hard to grasp: we don't want to trade our toxic carbon byproduct for toxic fission byproduct?

Because there's million times smaller amount of the fission byproducts for same energy produced? And all the arguments why it's worse than coal are political.

Re: Nuclear power may be the key to least-cost, zero-emission electricity systems

#9
post #2

Why is it so hard to grasp: we don't want to trade our toxic carbon byproduct for toxic fission byproduct?

We don't want the toxic waste from Solar panel production nor the industrial waste or the noise pollution from windmills either.

At some point we'll have to chose the lesser evil, and most of the good rivers have already been dammed so more hydro isn't really the solution.

A combination of renewables, nuclear base power, reduced power needs, smart grid load management, and synth fuel production during peak production seems like the best bet for something that might actually work.

Re: Nuclear power may be the key to least-cost, zero-emission electricity systems

#10
post #2

Why is it so hard to grasp: we don't want to trade our toxic carbon byproduct for toxic fission byproduct?

Yes we do want to trade that. The toxic carbon byproduct goes into the air and causes massive disruption to the lives of billions of people. The toxic fission byproduct is tiny and goes underground in the middle of the desert and disrupts zero people's lives.
Post reply on HN