Live data from Hacker News

Event-driven access to my home after a run

randywestergren.com

1–10 of 84 posts

Re: Event-driven access to my home after a run

#3
So if you turn off your phone for 5 minutes while staying at home and turn it on again, does your garage door open?

EDIT: Or do you need to go press a button on a webpage before going out for a run to make this work? The last part seems to suggest so.

Re: Event-driven access to my home after a run

#4
My feelings about these kinds of projects are a bit mixed. I certainly understand why, writing code that controls something in the real world is so much fun. However I actively avoid any kind of smart device in my home, beyond my vacuum cleaner. Having a computer control lighting, heating or access to my home is out of the question, I simply don't want to deal with it. I trust keys, switches and knobs.

Re: Event-driven access to my home after a run

#5

Still does not fix the initial issue of your phone going off before getting back home..

This is fixing that one precise incident he had, nothing else. He said that he came back from the run, turned on screen and the phone shutdown. With this solution the phone would open doors automatically. Cool project but it solves such narrow issue. It's like centering text in editor by adding spaces.

Re: Event-driven access to my home after a run

#6
post #4

My feelings about these kinds of projects are a bit mixed. I certainly understand why, writing code that controls something in the real world is so much fun. However I actively avoid any kind of smart device in my home, beyond my vacuum cleaner. Having a computer control lighting, heating or access to my home is out of the question, I simply don't want to deal with it. I trust keys, switches and knobs.

Dumb solution: hiding place for a key. Paradoxically it may be safer than smart solutions :)

Re: Event-driven access to my home after a run

#8
post #4

My feelings about these kinds of projects are a bit mixed. I certainly understand why, writing code that controls something in the real world is so much fun. However I actively avoid any kind of smart device in my home, beyond my vacuum cleaner. Having a computer control lighting, heating or access to my home is out of the question, I simply don't want to deal with it. I trust keys, switches and knobs.

Smart home stuff can't overcome the fundamental issue of complexity creep and the brittleness and unreliability inherent to it.

I've had a network connected soundbar bring down my home internet. My lights were set to re-enter the state they were in when they were last on, no way to turn those on without factory resetting them all and pairing all my devices again. My smart assistants were on a hair trigger, if anything tripped their wake word they would start a cacophony of complaints about not being able to connect to wifi and demands to be reset.

I'll give my smarthome crap one thing though, it's genuinely educational,

Post reply on HN