Live data from Hacker News

YouTube’s new censorship tactic is to limit streams that are too popular

reclaimthenet.org

1–10 of 21 posts

Re: YouTube’s new censorship tactic is to limit streams that are too popular

#6

This is like an indiscriminate low pass filter, how does this make any sense whatsoever ?

I imagine that there is a nontrivial amount of nobody channels with suddenly popular videos that are part of fraudulent ad revenue streams (if you can drive views at less $ per view than the ads earn you it's a net positive).

This is not to say that all suddenly popular channels are ad fraud. And it seems in character for YouTube to put a blanket constriction instead of doing the trickier job of dealing with separating genuine viral hits from fraudsters.

Or maybe they're working on something more nuanced but rolled out a rough measure to stem an aggressive wave of ad fraud. We'll never know because companies are tight lipped about that sort of thing.

Re: YouTube’s new censorship tactic is to limit streams that are too popular

#9
post #7

This only applies to new live streams, likely due to moderation and copyright concerns! Many platforms will have systems like this to prevent spam.

And the first instance of this I could easily find on Twitter was on Jan 8 that was in reply to somebody who tweeted a Youtube livestreamed dogsledding race: https://twitter.com/Cami5320/status/1479893333480599555

Re: YouTube’s new censorship tactic is to limit streams that are too popular

#10
Before people start making conspiracies theories, I want to mention a reasonable explanation that answers the following question: how could it be in Youtube’s financial interest to block views from small channels that go viral?

I think the answer must be related to an effort to reduce the amount of unauthorized copyrighted material or fraud on the platform. Currently the majority of such material/fraud on youtube is uploaded by small channels who can create another channel as necessary. Throttling small accounts is one possible way to combat this.

Post reply on HN