Live data from Hacker News

Common Jobs in a Medieval City

medievalists.net

1–10 of 193 posts

Re: Common Jobs in a Medieval City

#5
post #2

I wonder what the most common jobs are in a modern city. Probably all bullshit.

bullshit in whose opinion? As someone who does not believe in god, are all of the church related jobs bullshit? Or are they not, since a lot of people want churches and their services? If a job exists, there's apparently at least one person who wants it done.

Re: Common Jobs in a Medieval City

#6

Striking that there were more shoemakers than tailors.

I would expect that. Clothes last significantly longer than shoes (you can wear a cheap T-Shirt for way over 5 years, but even good midrange shoes start to fall apart after 2 years). It is also fairly easy to repair or even make clothes at home. But shoes?

Re: Common Jobs in a Medieval City

#7
post #2

I wonder what the most common jobs are in a modern city. Probably all bullshit.

bullshit in whose opinion? As someone who does not believe in god, are all of the church related jobs bullshit? Or are they not, since a lot of people want churches and their services? If a job exists, there's apparently at least one person who wants it done.

I think the parent quote may be in reference to David Graeber's commentary on "bullshit jobs".

Re: Common Jobs in a Medieval City

#9
post #2

I wonder what the most common jobs are in a modern city. Probably all bullshit.

I guess a recent pandemic would have shown which jobs were important these days:

Farmers Truck Drivers Shop Staff Medical Specialists Teachers Infrastructure specialists (power,fuel,extending into IT work) --- Purveyors of leisure activities, bars/brewing, restaurants/takeaways, online gaming, gambling --- Venture capitalists and financial experts Consultants specializing in skimming and offshoring Sales, marketing and influencers

I'll let you assign the weightings

Re: Common Jobs in a Medieval City

#10
post #6

Striking that there were more shoemakers than tailors.

I would expect that. Clothes last significantly longer than shoes (you can wear a cheap T-Shirt for way over 5 years, but even good midrange shoes start to fall apart after 2 years). It is also fairly easy to repair or even make clothes at home. But shoes?

I'd say one would suffer a lot more with borked shoes than torn upper clothing.
Post reply on HN