Live data from Hacker News

We May Never Get to Herd Immunity

thinkglobalhealth.org

1–10 of 38 posts

Re: We May Never Get to Herd Immunity

#3

Just in relation to the United States, I think we could increase vaccination compliance exponentially if getting vaccinated meant no longer having to wear a mask, social distance etc. Where is the carrot?

Where's the stick? How would the US enforce the "get vaccinated or wear a mask" rule? I can't think of any way to do this that isn't massively invasive, and I don't see this as being politically viable in most democratic countries.

Re: We May Never Get to Herd Immunity

#4

Just in relation to the United States, I think we could increase vaccination compliance exponentially if getting vaccinated meant no longer having to wear a mask, social distance etc. Where is the carrot?

Significantly decreasing your chance of catching an awful, potentially fatal, disease is not a carrot?

Re: We May Never Get to Herd Immunity

#6

Just in relation to the United States, I think we could increase vaccination compliance exponentially if getting vaccinated meant no longer having to wear a mask, social distance etc. Where is the carrot?

Significantly decreasing your chance of catching an awful, potentially fatal, disease is not a carrot?

Many of us are not onboard with that narrative.

Re: We May Never Get to Herd Immunity

#7

Just in relation to the United States, I think we could increase vaccination compliance exponentially if getting vaccinated meant no longer having to wear a mask, social distance etc. Where is the carrot?

Pay people $250 to receive the first dose and another $250 for the second dose. In cash, on site, immediately after you get your shot. Individuals aged 16 and over only. No citizenship test: give the money to undocumented immigrants too, as long as they receive the vaccine. Pay for it with deficit spending.

Re: We May Never Get to Herd Immunity

#9
post #3

Just in relation to the United States, I think we could increase vaccination compliance exponentially if getting vaccinated meant no longer having to wear a mask, social distance etc. Where is the carrot?

Where's the stick? How would the US enforce the "get vaccinated or wear a mask" rule? I can't think of any way to do this that isn't massively invasive, and I don't see this as being politically viable in most democratic countries.

Weird. Countries like South Korea and Israel don't need a stick. Their citizens happily volunteer to receive a shot.
Post reply on HN