Live data from Hacker News

Repairability

psankar.blogspot.com

1–10 of 68 posts

Re: Repairability

#4
Not that it's a justification, per se, but a lot of modern laptops won't boot without a battery. The power adapter often can't provide sufficient power to spin everything up at boot, and needs the battery as a buffer (this is why, if you run your macbook battery completely flat, it needs to charge for a few minutes before it can boot back up).

Re: Repairability

#5

Not that it's a justification, per se, but a lot of modern laptops won't boot without a battery. The power adapter often can't provide sufficient power to spin everything up at boot, and needs the battery as a buffer (this is why, if you run your macbook battery completely flat, it needs to charge for a few minutes before it can boot back up).

That sounds like a load of bollocks. A laptop, really?. Wish someone on HN can enlighten me.

Re: Repairability

#6
“ Thankfully Apple is not yet making cars, otherwise, to change Engine oil, we may have to dissasemble the headlamps, engine, transmission, differential, etc. ”

Interestingly changing the oil in a lot of prissy super cars require exactly this.

Re: Repairability

#8

Not that it's a justification, per se, but a lot of modern laptops won't boot without a battery. The power adapter often can't provide sufficient power to spin everything up at boot, and needs the battery as a buffer (this is why, if you run your macbook battery completely flat, it needs to charge for a few minutes before it can boot back up).

Why are laptops being sold with insufficient power adapters then? That also sounds just flat wrong. Most non-gaming laptops have power supplies with significantly higher outputs than their maximum power draw, and the boot-up surge is incredibly tiny. I would be flatly amazed if a MacBook boot up power draw was even 10% higher than system power draw under maximum load.

Re: Repairability

#9

Never had a bulky battery in any Mac. Must be something about the climate ...

I have - three times (if an iPad counts). This in cold non-polluted danish climate.

You can’t blame it on the climate just because you have never experienced it.

NB.: How many mac’s are your statistic based upon < 100? I think we need the big numbers...

Re: Repairability

#10

Not that it's a justification, per se, but a lot of modern laptops won't boot without a battery. The power adapter often can't provide sufficient power to spin everything up at boot, and needs the battery as a buffer (this is why, if you run your macbook battery completely flat, it needs to charge for a few minutes before it can boot back up).

Why are laptops being sold with insufficient power adapters then? That also sounds just flat wrong. Most non-gaming laptops have power supplies with significantly higher outputs than their maximum power draw, and the boot-up surge is incredibly tiny. I would be flatly amazed if a MacBook boot up power draw was even 10% higher than system power draw under maximum load.

It’s cheaper - more profit for the OEM. And booting without battery is likely considered a corner case, thus $$$
Post reply on HN