Live data from Hacker News

The Relative Weirdness of Birds

theweek.com

1–10 of 20 posts

Re: The Relative Weirdness of Birds

#2
The paper about which is written there is:

https://irispublishers.com/sjrr/pdf/SJRR.MS.ID.000540.pdf

and, to warn anybody expecting more, ends with:

"Acknowledgements

We thank Big Bird from Sesame Street for comments on the manuscript. Several trained monkeys transcribed videos."

Also: "Published Date: April 01, 2020"

In short: meh. Doesn't even appear to be funny, especially especially when "covered" on April 15, 2020, for my understanding of what is actually funny:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yL_-1d9OSdk

.

Re: The Relative Weirdness of Birds

#5
It's mildly amusing, sure, but publishing a rehash of a joke made on April 1st two weeks later, on April 15th, feels like seeing someone lag in real life. The paper should have been just left alone to be discovered by someone later as a fun curio. Especially since The Week seems to be a completely serious website the rest of the time, what a weird choice to publish that article two weeks after April Fool's.

Re: The Relative Weirdness of Birds

#7

It's mildly amusing, sure, but publishing a rehash of a joke made on April 1st two weeks later, on April 15th, feels like seeing someone lag in real life. The paper should have been just left alone to be discovered by someone later as a fun curio. Especially since The Week seems to be a completely serious website the rest of the time, what a weird choice to publish that article two weeks after April Fool's.

It's not just a joke, it has a serious purpose.

From the article > it does seem to prove his point: That the Scientific Journal of Research & Reviews is among dozens of "predatory journals" that publish low-quality or unreviewed papers, often for an exorbitant fee.

Re: The Relative Weirdness of Birds

#10
post #2

The paper about which is written there is: https://irispublishers.com/sjrr/pdf/SJRR.MS.ID.000540.pdf and, to warn anybody expecting more, ends with: "Acknowledgements We thank Big Bird from Sesame Street for comments on the manuscript. Several trained monkeys transcribed videos." Also: "Published Date: April 01, 2020" In short: meh. Doesn't even appear to be funny, especially especially when "covered" on April 15, 20…

Summary much appreciated though.
Post reply on HN