Live data from Hacker News

Facebook needs to quit with its thuggish attitude

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 38 posts

Facebook needs to quit with its thuggish attitude

#1
My Facebook profile was disabled for the second, and what seems the last time ("We will not be able to reactivate your account, nor will you be able to recover any content within the account. This decision is final.") on Sunday. The reason, too much "activity"?!?! Over the year and a half I have had my profile, I had amassed hundreds of pictures, hundreds of personal messages, many links/bookmarks, and hundreds of useful personal contacts; and all have now been lost due to Facebook egregious and bull doggish attitude.

The first time my account was disabled, I was doing something as simple as thanking all my contacts individually for their birthday wishes. Not been given the specifics to why I was banned this time around, but I’m sure it was a combination of adding friends, mass emailing (sent out a group email to my Facebook group!).

The ridiculous rules to use Facebook within limitations, and limit ones networking on a networking website are absolutely absurd. Furthermore, these "limitations" aren’t even published, so one is working in the dark, without any knowledge of whether they are going to break a rule of not.

With no way to back up any of the Facebook content, losing all that data is akin to losing data on ones own personal computer. And not only do they delete your account, they remove all pictures you uploaded to groups, delete all the wall posts you ever made on anyone’s profile, remove the tags off all the pictures you were in, remove you off all your contacts friends list, de-admin you from the group you created… essentially, making it such that "you don’t exist, and you never existed" ('1984' anyone?). of Facebook.

A quick search on Google shows that banning users is more common than fish and chips (I’m from England). The comments on the following blog make for an interesting read:

http://prez.wordpress.com/2006/10/16/facebook-has-a-post-limit

"facebook disabled my account for adding too many people. i dont understand…if the point of facebook is to add friends, why is there now a limit on how many people you add."

"I was just disabled for not being verified with my school network."

"I just got disabled for posting too many comments on group walls!"

"I have been disabled twice… and this is my second time… I do nothing! Just post on walls.. I don’t abuse anyone… I don’t even make fun of other people… I mean what the heck?"

"Facebook just disabled my account. I started a group for people with the same last name as me and i started sending messages to people with the same name to join."

"I added a number of friends from my College because of the mere fact that people in the same school should know one another."

"They said I wall posted too much"

"I made a charity event and sent out over 100 invites.. as people started requesting information, i was mailing people back."

"Yea so like i was Poking some friends last night right and it said slow down or ELES! your Account will be Disabled."

"Facebook, in their infinite wisdom, has decided to disable me. They claim that I do not go to Plum Senior High School."

"My Facebook account was disabled because Facebook felt my name was fake. My name is of Indian background."

"My account was disabled a few hours ago.. because I was friending too many people."

Has anyone else encountered this? And if so, how did they deal with it? Are you a Facebook employee? Can I have my account back?

Re: Facebook needs to quit with its thuggish attitude

#7
Sorry to hear this, especially as it sounds like you do not have a backup. What you may consider a false positive are common problems with FB/eBay/PayPal and the like who try to act in the best interest of the masses.

If you are unable to resolve this, I can ask my friends who work there to see what they can do.

Re: Facebook needs to quit with its thuggish attitude

#8
post #5
post #2

...oh, and should anyone wish to re-enable my account, it was registered under: miahs101[at]hotmail.com (yes, it's a desperate attempt, but I might aswell).

Why would you even want your account back? Facebook doesn't deserve your page views.

He detailed that in his post. They have control over his personal information and he wants it back.

Is there a FB app that would backup your list of contacts and other information you'd like to have? Is it against the ToS?

Re: Facebook needs to quit with its thuggish attitude

#9
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why would you even want your account back? Facebook doesn't deserve your page views.

He detailed that in his post. They have control over his personal information and he wants it back. Is there a FB app that would backup your list of contacts and other information you'd like to have? Is it against the ToS?

Ya, this would be against the ToS.

Re: Facebook needs to quit with its thuggish attitude

#10
post #7

Sorry to hear this, especially as it sounds like you do not have a backup. What you may consider a false positive are common problems with FB/eBay/PayPal and the like who try to act in the best interest of the masses. If you are unable to resolve this, I can ask my friends who work there to see what they can do.

That's why I like this community-what a nice thing to offer. .
Post reply on HN