Live data from Hacker News

Password Generator

beta.browxy.com

1–10 of 44 posts

Re: Password Generator

#2
This generates the password on a server you don't control.

I recommend not using it.

Using 'tr -dc A-Za-z0-9 < /dev/urandom | head -c $length' is more secure and available on your linux or osx machine even more easily than waiting a second for a server to run some java off in a magic black box.

Re: Password Generator

#3
post #2

This generates the password on a server you don't control. I recommend not using it. Using 'tr -dc A-Za-z0-9 < /dev/urandom | head -c $length' is more secure and available on your linux or osx machine even more easily than waiting a second for a server to run some java off in a magic black box.

If you get "tr: Illegal byte sequence" you can prepend 'LC_ALL=C ' before the 'tr' to prevent tr from trying to treat the stream as a unicode sequence.

Re: Password Generator

#4
I created something similar ~2 decades ago in perl. It would spit out a long list of passwords in text format so you could chose one without the server knowing what you chose.

Today, keepass does the job just fine.

Re: Password Generator

#5
post #2

This generates the password on a server you don't control. I recommend not using it. Using 'tr -dc A-Za-z0-9 < /dev/urandom | head -c $length' is more secure and available on your linux or osx machine even more easily than waiting a second for a server to run some java off in a magic black box.

This isn't a great site or anything and you're right that password should be generated client-side. But not everyone is one Linux or Mac and sometimes it's just easier to Google "password generator" than remembering that command.

Your comment reminds me of the infamous Dropbox comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224

Re: Password Generator

#6
post #4

I created something similar ~2 decades ago in perl. It would spit out a long list of passwords in text format so you could chose one without the server knowing what you chose. Today, keepass does the job just fine.

That's a nice idea! I just created this password generator for fun like other utilities in java but I don't know just this one generated so many interest. You can see the source code using the button to the bottom right (the one that has 1's and 0's)

Re: Password Generator

#7
post #5
post #2

This generates the password on a server you don't control. I recommend not using it. Using 'tr -dc A-Za-z0-9 < /dev/urandom | head -c $length' is more secure and available on your linux or osx machine even more easily than waiting a second for a server to run some java off in a magic black box.

This isn't a great site or anything and you're right that password should be generated client-side. But not everyone is one Linux or Mac and sometimes it's just easier to Google "password generator" than remembering that command. Your comment reminds me of the infamous Dropbox comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224

Yes you right I just created this password generator for fun in the browxy online compiler. The UI is auto-generated with a tool that the site provide. I'm just curious why this tool caused so many interest and wondering what other tools can be built that cause this type of interest...

Re: Password Generator

#8
post #5
post #2

This generates the password on a server you don't control. I recommend not using it. Using 'tr -dc A-Za-z0-9 < /dev/urandom | head -c $length' is more secure and available on your linux or osx machine even more easily than waiting a second for a server to run some java off in a magic black box.

This isn't a great site or anything and you're right that password should be generated client-side. But not everyone is one Linux or Mac and sometimes it's just easier to Google "password generator" than remembering that command. Your comment reminds me of the infamous Dropbox comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224

Password managers and browsers themselves can generate passwords. Generating passwords with a website it a terrible idea, googling "password generator" and going to some random website is an even worse variant of the same idea.

Re: Password Generator

#9
post #5
post #2

This generates the password on a server you don't control. I recommend not using it. Using 'tr -dc A-Za-z0-9 < /dev/urandom | head -c $length' is more secure and available on your linux or osx machine even more easily than waiting a second for a server to run some java off in a magic black box.

This isn't a great site or anything and you're right that password should be generated client-side. But not everyone is one Linux or Mac and sometimes it's just easier to Google "password generator" than remembering that command. Your comment reminds me of the infamous Dropbox comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224

There are plenty of actually secure and usable password generators, such as the one integrated with keepass / 1password / etc.

I'm sure there are secure websites to do it too. This isn't it though.

The dropbox comment isn't relevant. It's a bias to say "I remember this thing was criticized in a similar way but succeeded" and map that on to "so other criticisms aren't valid".

It's far more often than things seem unlikely to succeed to critics, and then quietly fail than that things seem unlikely to succeed to critics, but then succeed. After all, almost everything ever made doesn't see widespread success.

Our brain does remember the latter cases more, and that leads to the bias.

I see it most commonly with the phrase "X started out small too" as a defence for why something small will grow to something big, when in reality that's cherry picking massively.

Re: Password Generator

#10
post #4

I created something similar ~2 decades ago in perl. It would spit out a long list of passwords in text format so you could chose one without the server knowing what you chose. Today, keepass does the job just fine.

Instead of a search space of 1 you augmented it to N which is likely <= 2^10. Still a pretty terrible idea to trust a password like that.
Post reply on HN