Live data from Hacker News

On Becoming One (Collective Consciousness and the Fermi Paradox)

medium.com

1–10 of 34 posts

Re: On Becoming One (Collective Consciousness and the Fermi Paradox)

#3
post #2

An addictive, codependent, smothering one-ness delivered with unquestioning religious fervour sounds like something I’d start an armed resistance against.

I imagine many people will feel the same way. Do you think the Oneness will let you alone or pull you in for your own good :-)

Re: On Becoming One (Collective Consciousness and the Fermi Paradox)

#4
It will happen across such a long and large gradient that no one will know or ever understand it.

Does a single ant “know” what the whole colony wants? Yet one can describe the colony as a whole in many ways: finding food, reacting to threats, etc.

Does a single neuron “know” it is part of a brain? Yet the brain acts as a system, responding to stimuli in a coordinated fashion.

Hypothesis: we are already “one”, we just don’t know it, and can never truly know it, at an individual level.

Re: On Becoming One (Collective Consciousness and the Fermi Paradox)

#5

It will happen across such a long and large gradient that no one will know or ever understand it. Does a single ant “know” what the whole colony wants? Yet one can describe the colony as a whole in many ways: finding food, reacting to threats, etc. Does a single neuron “know” it is part of a brain? Yet the brain acts as a system, responding to stimuli in a coordinated fashion. Hypothesis: we are already “one”, we jus…

We will become 'one' who we will be able to actually understand.

Re: On Becoming One (Collective Consciousness and the Fermi Paradox)

#6
post #3
post #2

An addictive, codependent, smothering one-ness delivered with unquestioning religious fervour sounds like something I’d start an armed resistance against.

I imagine many people will feel the same way. Do you think the Oneness will let you alone or pull you in for your own good :-)

If you can communicate with it at all, you have already been pulled in.

Re: On Becoming One (Collective Consciousness and the Fermi Paradox)

#7

It will happen across such a long and large gradient that no one will know or ever understand it. Does a single ant “know” what the whole colony wants? Yet one can describe the colony as a whole in many ways: finding food, reacting to threats, etc. Does a single neuron “know” it is part of a brain? Yet the brain acts as a system, responding to stimuli in a coordinated fashion. Hypothesis: we are already “one”, we jus…

I like the analogy to neurons but since we are sentient being this is a second order collective and I think we will know, at least to a degree, that we are merging.

Re: On Becoming One (Collective Consciousness and the Fermi Paradox)

#10
I've often thought along these same lines (c.f. Asimov's Galaxia concept) but I think that this one-ness will inherently be limited by distance. Thoughts can be propagated across a planet pretty quickly but if we become a multi-planet civilization I would expect each planet to have it's own "one mind" (or whatever you want to call it) simply because of communication latency.
Post reply on HN