Live data from Hacker News

YouTube Said to Be Fined Up to $200M for Children’s Privacy Violations

nytimes.com

1–10 of 156 posts

Re: YouTube Said to Be Fined Up to $200M for Children’s Privacy Violations

#2
I for one am glad at this though I am sure the fine could have been exponentially larger. The fact that YouTube can go here and say their platform is only intended for 13 year olds and up is a joke. Their are thousands of shows targeted directly at my kids. I can even clearly hear one video my kid likes to watch starts out with saying “look kids” so tell me how that is not directed at kids. I use an adblocker but when I go to my moms she doesn’t have it set up on her iPad. The kids shows are bombarded with ads for adult products like cars or you name it. They are marketing towards kids and I can’t stand it.

Re: YouTube Said to Be Fined Up to $200M for Children’s Privacy Violations

#3
As I understand it, YouTube remains unprofitable to this date. What game is Google playing at here? Creators are unhappy with the strong arming, users are displeased with the ads and the comments and, well, everything. Parents are unhappy with the creepy videos targeting children. YouTube music is a travesty and is likely to fail like all the other half-baked Google products. YouTube gaming... is dead. Now they're getting fined for something they could have easily avoided.

What in the hell is Google doing, and why do they suck at this so bad? I can imagine so many better product experiences. Why can't they get their act together?

Re: YouTube Said to Be Fined Up to $200M for Children’s Privacy Violations

#4
post #3

As I understand it, YouTube remains unprofitable to this date. What game is Google playing at here? Creators are unhappy with the strong arming, users are displeased with the ads and the comments and, well, everything. Parents are unhappy with the creepy videos targeting children. YouTube music is a travesty and is likely to fail like all the other half-baked Google products. YouTube gaming... is dead. Now they're ge…

Yeah right. The competition is doing so well. Try running a video hosting service within the frameworks of the law. It's still the most popular service by a longshot. Classic HN being delusional again.

Re: YouTube Said to Be Fined Up to $200M for Children’s Privacy Violations

#5
post #3

As I understand it, YouTube remains unprofitable to this date. What game is Google playing at here? Creators are unhappy with the strong arming, users are displeased with the ads and the comments and, well, everything. Parents are unhappy with the creepy videos targeting children. YouTube music is a travesty and is likely to fail like all the other half-baked Google products. YouTube gaming... is dead. Now they're ge…

> As I understand it, YouTube remains unprofitable to this date.

Source?

Re: YouTube Said to Be Fined Up to $200M for Children’s Privacy Violations

#6
post #4
post #3

As I understand it, YouTube remains unprofitable to this date. What game is Google playing at here? Creators are unhappy with the strong arming, users are displeased with the ads and the comments and, well, everything. Parents are unhappy with the creepy videos targeting children. YouTube music is a travesty and is likely to fail like all the other half-baked Google products. YouTube gaming... is dead. Now they're ge…

Yeah right. The competition is doing so well. Try running a video hosting service within the frameworks of the law. It's still the most popular service by a longshot. Classic HN being delusional again.

Reddit, Netflix, HBO, Disney+, Twitch

Edit: Facebook, Twitter

Re: YouTube Said to Be Fined Up to $200M for Children’s Privacy Violations

#7
With all the complaints against Youtube, I don't know how they can still be so out of touch with everyone.

It's almost as if they're doing it deliberately. They're begging for competition to take over their unprofitable business. Nobody wants to step up.

Re: YouTube Said to Be Fined Up to $200M for Children’s Privacy Violations

#8
post #5
post #3

As I understand it, YouTube remains unprofitable to this date. What game is Google playing at here? Creators are unhappy with the strong arming, users are displeased with the ads and the comments and, well, everything. Parents are unhappy with the creepy videos targeting children. YouTube music is a travesty and is likely to fail like all the other half-baked Google products. YouTube gaming... is dead. Now they're ge…

> As I understand it, YouTube remains unprofitable to this date. Source?

Nothing recent, but Google does not disclose figures from YouTube.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/viewers-dont-add-up-to-profit-f...

https://www.google.com/amp/s/fortune.com/2016/10/18/youtube-... (not sure how to un-ampify this)

Re: YouTube Said to Be Fined Up to $200M for Children’s Privacy Violations

#9
post #6
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah right. The competition is doing so well. Try running a video hosting service within the frameworks of the law. It's still the most popular service by a longshot. Classic HN being delusional again.

Reddit, Netflix, HBO, Disney+, Twitch Edit: Facebook, Twitter

You do realise that Disney, HBO and Netflix are one-way distributors right? They don't even belong in that list.

Re: YouTube Said to Be Fined Up to $200M for Children’s Privacy Violations

#10
post #6
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah right. The competition is doing so well. Try running a video hosting service within the frameworks of the law. It's still the most popular service by a longshot. Classic HN being delusional again.

Reddit, Netflix, HBO, Disney+, Twitch Edit: Facebook, Twitter

None of those compete directly with user-uploaded content of arbitrary length. Vimeo and Dailymotion are the nearest competitors.
Post reply on HN