Live data from Hacker News

Amazon has proven unable or unwilling to effectively police third-party sellers

wsj.com

1–10 of 339 posts

Re: Amazon has proven unable or unwilling to effectively police third-party sellers

#2
Amazon has calculated they're not liable if they don't spend appropriate oversight. It's a type of fraud like tax evasion that they can legally commit, because all that will happen is in 5 - 10 years some government will spend three years suing them to change the contrived status quo that would see any retail shop shut down.

Re: Amazon has proven unable or unwilling to effectively police third-party sellers

#3
We used to buy from Amazon since it was a stamp of quality. I tried buying a usb-c cable for my mac mini, and it was terrible. So many brands and no way of knowing what to get. Today you might as well buy from Ebay.

What online store exists today, where I can be guaranteed to buy quality things? Do they no longer exist?

Re: Amazon has proven unable or unwilling to effectively police third-party sellers

#4
Anyone else think this is on purpose? Now they can remove all third party sellers from their platform and cite a trust & safety risk. They've been neglecting sellers on the platform for a decade. Why else would the API be absolutely ancient? A huge change is coming.

Re: Amazon has proven unable or unwilling to effectively police third-party sellers

#5

We used to buy from Amazon since it was a stamp of quality. I tried buying a usb-c cable for my mac mini, and it was terrible. So many brands and no way of knowing what to get. Today you might as well buy from Ebay. What online store exists today, where I can be guaranteed to buy quality things? Do they no longer exist?

The odd thing is eBay's quality is now easier to assess than Amazon's.

Re: Amazon has proven unable or unwilling to effectively police third-party sellers

#7

We used to buy from Amazon since it was a stamp of quality. I tried buying a usb-c cable for my mac mini, and it was terrible. So many brands and no way of knowing what to get. Today you might as well buy from Ebay. What online store exists today, where I can be guaranteed to buy quality things? Do they no longer exist?

When was Amazon ever a 'stamp of quality'? You can still buy a brand-name cable from Best Buy or other retailers that people used to use before everyone was trying to save a few pennies.

Re: Amazon has proven unable or unwilling to effectively police third-party sellers

#8

We used to buy from Amazon since it was a stamp of quality. I tried buying a usb-c cable for my mac mini, and it was terrible. So many brands and no way of knowing what to get. Today you might as well buy from Ebay. What online store exists today, where I can be guaranteed to buy quality things? Do they no longer exist?

It used to be when I wanted a quality item, I'd click "Ships from and sold by Amazon". They removed that option. Now I cancelled Prime and either buy from other well known retailers, or click "Condition: Used" on EBay. Amazon now is just FBA Alibaba with same lack of quality control.

Re: Amazon has proven unable or unwilling to effectively police third-party sellers

#9
post #5

We used to buy from Amazon since it was a stamp of quality. I tried buying a usb-c cable for my mac mini, and it was terrible. So many brands and no way of knowing what to get. Today you might as well buy from Ebay. What online store exists today, where I can be guaranteed to buy quality things? Do they no longer exist?

The odd thing is eBay's quality is now easier to assess than Amazon's.

And eBay is often way cheaper to boot.

Re: Amazon has proven unable or unwilling to effectively police third-party sellers

#10

Anyone else think this is on purpose? Now they can remove all third party sellers from their platform and cite a trust & safety risk. They've been neglecting sellers on the platform for a decade. Why else would the API be absolutely ancient? A huge change is coming.

> Why else would the API be absolutely ancient? A huge change is coming.

What motivations do they have to change it? Amazon has very little incentive to change an API that is a cash cow. The AdWords API is much the same. It's a SOAP api that largely hasn't changed in 5+ years.

Post reply on HN