Live data from Hacker News

A new AMP update shows how it can infiltrate every corner of the internet

onezero.medium.com

1–10 of 93 posts

Re: A new AMP update shows how it can infiltrate every corner of the internet

#2
I've published AMP only sites and regular optimized sites. My niche is usually large informational sites. Minifying and removing unused CSS and inlining everything has resulted in better indexing than similarly positioned AMP sites.

The resulting pages are smaller than their AMP equivalents and load with less requests.

On my non-news sites I can say that I get more traffic without AMP.

Re: A new AMP update shows how it can infiltrate every corner of the internet

#3
I have no trouble getting websites with good web performance to rank above AMP results. I like to think I have beaten them even when I'm slightly below them, because they trap their visitors in the AMP silo, while I am offering them a full site with probably better performance overall.

The only reason to offer AMP is to get into the news caroussel.

Re: A new AMP update shows how it can infiltrate every corner of the internet

#7
I think that the mobile trend was blown way out of proportion. I very often find myself clicking on the 'Browse desktop version' button when browsing a so-called 'mobile-friendly' version of a site. Is the look of the website really more important than the content and functionality? For me, it's not. This is just another example of a big tech monopoly imposing their highly opinionated ideas on billions of people.

Also, I hate it when a mobile site keeps reminding me to install the app. This is extremely mobile-unfriendly. Google ought to punish those sites.

Re: A new AMP update shows how it can infiltrate every corner of the internet

#9
Google intentionally gimps Firefox on Android, by serving an old-school page. Using an addon (which you can on mobile Fx, and not on Chrome), fixes this by editing the UA string when visiting Google.

Getting the "nice experience", however, gives me amp links. And when I click on them, I'm unable to scroll?! It doesn't matter if it loads fast, when I cannot read beyond the fold.

It also breaks the "open in app" I normally have. If the link is a reddit link, for instance, I can press an icon in Firefox to have it open in "Reddit is fun".

Post reply on HN