Live data from Hacker News

China is harvesting organs from detainees, tribunal concludes

theguardian.com

1–9 of 9 posts

Re: China is harvesting organs from detainees, tribunal concludes

#3
Sci-fi author Larry Niven has written a number of stories partly exploring the "Ship of Theseus" idea extended to organ transplants and medicine. In one future from Larry Niven's Sci-fi stories, organ transplants could cure almost anything and even extend life. As a result, more and more criminal infractions started to carry the death penalty, in indirect response to the demand for more organs. Such a process would be easier to initiate in a government structure like China's, where there are fewer powerful means of ensuring government accountability, and where individual rights are not enshrined. The current climate in 2019 in the West, where mob rule can result in trial by social media, is also concerning in relation to this scenario.

Re: China is harvesting organs from detainees, tribunal concludes

#4

Sci-fi author Larry Niven has written a number of stories partly exploring the "Ship of Theseus" idea extended to organ transplants and medicine. In one future from Larry Niven's Sci-fi stories, organ transplants could cure almost anything and even extend life. As a result, more and more criminal infractions started to carry the death penalty, in indirect response to the demand for more organs. Such a process would b…

China's social credit score system would be an easy place for them to look for "undesirables" to use for livestock, create an ever shifting minimal level of political servitude to avoid execution.

Re: China is harvesting organs from detainees, tribunal concludes

#7
post #4

Sci-fi author Larry Niven has written a number of stories partly exploring the "Ship of Theseus" idea extended to organ transplants and medicine. In one future from Larry Niven's Sci-fi stories, organ transplants could cure almost anything and even extend life. As a result, more and more criminal infractions started to carry the death penalty, in indirect response to the demand for more organs. Such a process would b…

China's social credit score system would be an easy place for them to look for "undesirables" to use for livestock, create an ever shifting minimal level of political servitude to avoid execution.

https://orville.fandom.com/wiki/Majority_Rule

Re: China is harvesting organs from detainees, tribunal concludes

#9

Sci-fi author Larry Niven has written a number of stories partly exploring the "Ship of Theseus" idea extended to organ transplants and medicine. In one future from Larry Niven's Sci-fi stories, organ transplants could cure almost anything and even extend life. As a result, more and more criminal infractions started to carry the death penalty, in indirect response to the demand for more organs. Such a process would b…

once you have an in demand organ, are you somewhat immune to prosecution, akin to double jeopardy? they wont reharvest a kidney?