Live data from Hacker News

A Vasectomy for Every Newborn Boy

medium.com

1–3 of 3 posts

Re: A Vasectomy for Every Newborn Boy

#2
This treads too much on individuals freedom to me. What this is saying is that we don’t trust people to make grown up decisions about family planning, so let’s semi-permanently neuter them.

Using circumcising babies as the moral benchmark “we’ll it ain’t as bad as that” seems like a weak argument to me.

Re: A Vasectomy for Every Newborn Boy

#3

This treads too much on individuals freedom to me. What this is saying is that we don’t trust people to make grown up decisions about family planning, so let’s semi-permanently neuter them. Using circumcising babies as the moral benchmark “we’ll it ain’t as bad as that” seems like a weak argument to me.

Thank you for this.

Considering that vasectomies are completely reversible you're just giving people a safer form of birth control that they can opt out of any time. It's not about not trusting people. It's making individuals lives easier through the implementation of a default that allows for people to make more conscious decisions.