Live data from Hacker News

Associations Among School Absenteeism, G.I. and Respiratory Illness, and Income

cdc.gov

1–10 of 174 posts

Re: Associations Among School Absenteeism, G.I. and Respiratory Illness, and Income

#2
"Although the likelihood of missing any school days during the past year decreased with reduced income, among children missing school, those from low-income households missed more days of school than did children from higher income households. Although the reason for absenteeism cannot be ascertained from this analysis, these data underscore the importance of preventive measures, such as hand hygiene promotion and education, and the opportunity for both homes and schools to serve as an important point for implementation of public health preventive measures, including hand hygiene practice and education."

Re: Associations Among School Absenteeism, G.I. and Respiratory Illness, and Income

#3
post #2

"Although the likelihood of missing any school days during the past year decreased with reduced income, among children missing school, those from low-income households missed more days of school than did children from higher income households. Although the reason for absenteeism cannot be ascertained from this analysis, these data underscore the importance of preventive measures, such as hand hygiene promotion and ed…

That’s another issue itself buried inside of this report. Here’s the meat of what the report is bringing awareness to.

>Among children who had gastrointestinal illness, 84.6% (family income <$35,000), 86.1% ($35,000–$49,999), 90.3% ($50,000–$74,999), 89.6% ($75,000–$99,999), and 87.4% (≥$100,000) missed school in the past year. Similarly, 83.7% of children living below the poverty level with gastrointestinal illness missed school, compared with 88.3% of those living at or above the poverty level.

Re: Associations Among School Absenteeism, G.I. and Respiratory Illness, and Income

#4
This is well known to anyone who has worked in a public school system. My friend used to work as a sub. One day, she found a sick student and sent him home. Later, she was admonished by a teacher there: this kid lives in a garage, where they don't have a heater. At least, this kid can feel better in a warm class room. This happened in Milpitas, CA, last year.

Re: Associations Among School Absenteeism, G.I. and Respiratory Illness, and Income

#5
Fiji just introduced 5 days/yr of "Family Care Leave" on the 1st of Jan, 2019. The Act doesn't require there to be sickness involved, so while you can take leave to care for your sick family member, theoretically you can also do so to support them at a school rugby match: https://i.imgur.com/Ct0wv5D.png

Fiji is just barely above "third world" status. What's your excuse, USA?

Re: Associations Among School Absenteeism, G.I. and Respiratory Illness, and Income

#6
What sort of failed state does not mobilize to support and ease the pain of fellow humans living through such hardship.

By the way, “poor life choices” is not a valid argument.

Edit: ok, in view of the objections regarding the technical definiton of “failed state” let me reword it to “failed society”. It is closer to my own objection anyway

Re: Associations Among School Absenteeism, G.I. and Respiratory Illness, and Income

#7
post #5

Fiji just introduced 5 days/yr of "Family Care Leave" on the 1st of Jan, 2019. The Act doesn't require there to be sickness involved, so while you can take leave to care for your sick family member, theoretically you can also do so to support them at a school rugby match: https://i.imgur.com/Ct0wv5D.png Fiji is just barely above "third world" status. What's your excuse, USA?

In my experience all Americans want to help people in need, but when it comes to footing the bill, half of the population becomes very silent.

I don't mind paying 50/50 in taxes or around there.. I don't have to feel bad about not helping people in need in Denmark.

(Yes, yes, taxes does alleviate my personal responsibility for being a nice person who helps other people -- but small acts of kindness doesn't scale)

Re: Associations Among School Absenteeism, G.I. and Respiratory Illness, and Income

#8
post #5

Fiji just introduced 5 days/yr of "Family Care Leave" on the 1st of Jan, 2019. The Act doesn't require there to be sickness involved, so while you can take leave to care for your sick family member, theoretically you can also do so to support them at a school rugby match: https://i.imgur.com/Ct0wv5D.png Fiji is just barely above "third world" status. What's your excuse, USA?

US is optimized for individual gain, not societies gain as a whole.

This is the thing which attracts immigrants from all over the socialist/communist republics of the world and they are the ones who make it big.

No one wants to change that, there is double speak here when people do sympathize but when it comes to foot the bill, no tax payer is ready for that.

Re: Associations Among School Absenteeism, G.I. and Respiratory Illness, and Income

#9
post #6

What sort of failed state does not mobilize to support and ease the pain of fellow humans living through such hardship. By the way, “poor life choices” is not a valid argument. Edit: ok, in view of the objections regarding the technical definiton of “failed state” let me reword it to “failed society”. It is closer to my own objection anyway

It isn't surprising to hear "failed state" in case of U.S., but in this case a lot of people do not want to spend money to ease the pain of other people living nearby, because living nearby does not mean being close anymore. This isn't due to failed state, this is due to people not feeling very close to each other.

Re: Associations Among School Absenteeism, G.I. and Respiratory Illness, and Income

#10
post #6

What sort of failed state does not mobilize to support and ease the pain of fellow humans living through such hardship. By the way, “poor life choices” is not a valid argument. Edit: ok, in view of the objections regarding the technical definiton of “failed state” let me reword it to “failed society”. It is closer to my own objection anyway

Calling the US a failed state is pretty hyperbolic.

There are many, many countries in the world where a much larger fraction of the population is living in much poorer material conditions than in the US, and not just places like Syria or Somalia.

Actually, taking this study at face value, I'd guess that the fact that the poorest students only miss on average of 1 extra day of school per year due to illness is evidence that the US is not a failed state by any sort of global standard. I'd wager that that number is a lot higher in a lot of places.

Post reply on HN